Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

He Gets Pranked/Scared

Jeff the Killer

You were still a little mad at Jeff for hiding D/N from you.

Coincidently, Laughing Jack was furious at the psychotic murderer for chopping off his swirly cone nose.

"Are you sure that this'll scare him?" You asked skeptically.

"Of course. Jeff is absolutely terrified of them!" L.J laughed, clapping his hands together.

The sound of the backdoor opening was the cue to hide behind the couch.

"Y/N?" Jeff's voice echoed around the silent house.

You and L.J tried to conceal your sniggering as his footsteps drew closer.

Peeking out from either side, you could see Jeff's shadow.

He entered the lounge and froze, clapping his hands over his mouth to muffle a scream.

The adorable white fluffy bunny looked up, noise twitching and ears flattened.

Without further ado, Jeff span on his heel and fled to the safety of the basement.

Laughing Jack's laughter combined with yours could be heard from miles away.

"That was hilarious!"

"He almost wet himself!"

You suddenly stopped laughing.

"Y/N? Is something wrong?"

"L.J... Where did you get that bunny from?"

The monochrome clown chuckled nervously and was suddenly gone in a burst of candy.

You rolled your eyes and gathered up the candy to be eaten later while wondering what on earth you were going to do with the little fella.

BEN Drowned... In a puddle?

It was a rainy and stormy day/afternoon/that time after lunch and, suffering from the effects of a filling meal, you were both just lounging around.

Every time you closed your eyes, you saw those horrific images all over again.

Finally it came to light that you were in need of some serious revenge.

BEN was sleeping on the couch, occasionally snoring.

Stealthily and sneakily, you crept up on the elf and began wrapping chains around him.

After securely putting a padlock to ensure that he wouldn't be going anywhere, you began looking through YouTube for something suitable.

"Twelve hours of My Little Pony? No, I'm pretty sure that he loves that show... Ah ha!"

You selected the video and delicately used duct-tape to cover the laptop keyboard before sticking the loose ends to BEN.

You quickly expanded the screen, cranked up the volume, and pressed play.

BEN sleepily awoke as it started.

"H-huh...?"

We clawed. We chained... our hearts in vain. We jumped, never asking why...

"Y/N? What is this- OH SWEET MOTHER OF-"

I CAME IN LIKE A WRECKING BALL! I'VE NEVER HIT SO HARD IN LOVE!

BEN's eyes went wide and began to bleed.

"AAAAHHH!"

You couldn't help it and bent down to whisper in his ear.

"You've met with a terrible fate, haven't you?"