Friends don't kill friends(Creepypasta fanfiction)

I can't even

"This is EJ" I told Andy "he kind of ate your kidney."
She frowned "what happened to his eyes?" She asked.
I swatted her arm "oh my god you can just go around asking why people don't have eyes!" I scolded.
EJ laughed "you know that I'm blind not deaf right?"
Andy shook her head "are you sure this isn't a dream?"
Lui poked his head in our room "they found Andy's fake body." he informed us.
She frowned "what about school? I don't want to be retarded."
I shrugged "Slendy will teach us."
She shivered out of fear.
It's been a week and she still hasn't gotten over her fear of him but in her defense she did think that she watched her brother get killed by him.
That's another thing. Brian's seen to be avoiding coming home now that she's moved in. I think he can't stand what he did to her.
Andy and I followed Lui back into the living room and we all sat on the couch.
"They think a wolf ate her" Jeff told us.
Andy smiled at Jeff and then Lui.
She's made it very clear that she thinks that both of the Woods are hot.
Toby bust threw the front door and kicked a chair over.
"What's wrong?" I asked.
He didn't answer instead he threw Jeff to the ground.
"Don't you feel so good?" He yelled.
I stepped back from them and pulled Andy with me.
Lui pushed Toby off of Jeff and then pinned him down "what's wrong with you tick prick!?"
Toby's rage turned to tears "why did you have to come?" He sobbed "why does Jeff get you back? I didn't kill Lyra but Jeff killed you and he gets a second chance?!"
I ran over and hugged Toby.
Unlike Jeff he didn't get a say in his sibling's life or death.
Toby clung tightly to me and cried.
Andy helped Jeff up and looked at Toby. She didn't know his story....
"Lyra" Toby sobbed quietly then twitched.
Lui frowned "look, Toby I know you're upset but hurting Jeff won't bring your sister back."
Toby nodded but didn't let me go.
BEN appeared beside me then frowned "what's wrong with him?"
I looked up at him "where have you been?" I asked. When was the last time I'd seen him? 2 days ago? 3?
"Sally's " he answered "she needed help cleaning out Nina's room."
"Where's Nina?" Jeff asked.
BEN shrugged "maybe with Jane?"
I tried not to smile.
Toby stood up and pulled me up "waffles?" He asked.
I smiled and nodded "waffles"