Benny

4.5K 97 3
                                    

"So I finally getta meet this Benny?" I asked with a smile.

"Yes, now listen you got one rule. No falling for him." Dean said looking at me with a frown.

"I won't..... as long as he doesn't have a southern accent." I said with a smirk.

"You might be my sister but I'll kill you." He said glaring at me.

I laughed as we pulled up to Benny's place and we walked inside to see a tall guy standing beside a fireplace.

"Sorry Dean." I said with a wink.

He smacked the back of my head and I laughed as he introduced us.

"Benny meet (y/n)..... my baby sister." Dean said glaring at him.

"Nice to meet you Cher." Benny said shaking my hand.

"Pleasure is all mine." I said with a wink.

He chuckled and we talked for awhile before Dean left me with him.

"Remember you are to watch him and make sure he don't kill." Dean said before he left.

A couple months later

"Hey Benny do you know where my flannel is?" I asked looking around.

"Which one? Darlin you have about a hundred ones." He said walking into my room.

I quickly grabbed a shirt and covered myself with it. He laughed as he walked past me and into the bathroom.

"You need to learn how to knock! And it's the blue one!" I yelled with a laugh.

"On the couch! And why knock when you go to sleep in nothing but your underwear?" He asked with a wink.

I rolled my eyes and grabbed the flannel buttoning it up and putting my hair in a ponytail. I laughed as I saw Benny walk in and wink at me.

"I gotta go to work. I'll see you later darlin." He said kissing the my cheek.

I blushed as he turned away and walked out of the house leaving me alone with my thoughts. After awhile I heard my phone ring and I stood up and answered it.

"Hello?" I asked answering the phone.

"Hey it's Dean. I wanted to see how everything was going." He said softly.

"Going great." I said with a sigh.

"Okay what's wrong?" He asked with a sigh.

"I.... I think I'm fallin for Benny. I mean I can't sleep without dreaming. About him and I can't stop thinking about him when I'm awake either." I explained.

"(Y/n)... I told you not to fall for him. He is a vampire and your human. It won't work sis." He said with a sigh.

"I know, but.... I have never felt more normal then now. Here with Benny." I said sadly.

"Maybe you shouldn't stay.... I don't want you to get hurt." Dean said softly.

"Alright..... I guess I'll leave after he gets back." I said sadly.

"Okay I'll see you later sis." Dean said hanging up.

I groaned as I went to my room and grabbed my bag putting everything inside of it. I put down the shirt I was holding as I saw a picture of me and Benny at the dinner. I set on the bed and looked at the picture with a smile on my face. I laid the picture on my bed and finished packing. I put my stuff inside of my truck and went back inside and waited for Benny to get back. When he finally got back I saw he was covered in rain and I couldn't help but to laugh.

"You think this is funny Cher?" He asked smiling at me.

"I think it is hilarious." I said laughing.

I stopped laughing as he looked at me with a smirk and walked towards me.

"Oh no don't you even think about it. I can't get wet I have places to be." I said backing away from him.

"Where do you gotta be Cher?" He asked with a laugh.

"Dean.... needs my help so I'm leaving to help him." I said bitting my lip.

"When you gonna be back?" He asked looking down at me.

"Well..... you see..... I'm not coming back." I said looking away from him.

"What do you mean you ain't comin back?" He asked with a growl.

I bit my lip and looked up to see him looking down at me with a predatory snarl.

"I....... need to leave to help with everything going on.... I can't stay..... Dean needs my help." I said bitting my lip.

"Don't lie to me darlin." He snapped angrily.

"I.... I'm not lying Benny.... Dean needs my help so I'm leaving to help him." I said going to walk past him.

I felt his arm grab my wrist and pull me against him. I looked up and saw him glaring down at me. I felt him squeeze my wrist and I gasped as I tried to pull away.

"Tell. Me. The. Truth." He growled as he gripped my arm tightly.

"Okay! I didn't want to stay because I have feelings for you!" I snapped as I tried to get my arm lose.

He let go of my arm and I fell to the floor hitting my head on the table. I passed out and when I woke up I was on my bed in one of Benny's shirts. I set up and felt the room spin.

"I wouldn't get up darlin." Benny said walking into the room quickly.

"My head is killing me." I said bitting my lip.

"That's my fault..... I'm sorry I.... I didn't mean to hurt you it's just that.... when you said you where leaving and not coming back I thought it.... I thought it was because I was a monster." He said looking away.

"Benny, your not a monster. You are one of the kindest people I have ever met, and... that's why I care about you a lot." I said looking away.

"I care about you too (y/n).... you mean a lot to me." He said moving my face to look at him.

I smiled as he looked into my eyes and I leaned in and went to kiss him. My bedroom door slammed open and we pulled apart to see Dean and Sam with machetes.

"What is going on here?" Dean asked glaring at Benny.

"Well I was about to kill Benny." I said glaring at him.

"Dean I think everything is okay here." Sam said putting his machete away.

"Oh hello no it isn't! Sam he could hurt her!" Dean snapped angrily.

"Dean! Enough! I am happy here. The happiest I have ever been! Benny has kept me safe and means the world to me and I don't care what you think! I'm in love with him!" I yelled as I went to stand up.

I felt my legs shake and Benny grabbed me and helped me stand up.

"Okay.... we are gone." Dean said as he and Sam left.

I looked up at Benny and he smiled down at me.

"So you love me?" He asked with a chuckle.

"Yes I love you. You bastard." I said with a laugh.

"Good cause I love you too Cher." He said pulling me into a kiss.

Supernatural imaginesWhere stories live. Discover now