The Bad Boy Cares? | Completed √

Chapter 43

Previously
"Do you love him?"

Now
"I don't know, I don't think I'm at that point yet. I'm getting close, but I don't want to rush into things and say things that I'm going to regret"

"Understandable, don't worry" she smiles and I give her a small smile back

"So how are things with you and Jay?"

"Amazing"

"Aw, how cute, you're blushing" A small grin places itself on my lips

"So, let's pretend this isn't my brother we are talking about. Makes things a bit less awkward"

"When did you two first started ya know?" I ask, as I wiggle my eyebrows

"2 weeks after our first date. I know it's fast, but I was ready for it and come on, who can resist him?" she smiles and bites her lip

"Apparently you can't" I smirk and wink

"Does he treat you right?" I narrow my eyes at my own question

"Not really, he has never bought me chocolate" she says playfully

"Guess I have to learn him a lesson tomorrow" I sigh disappointed and give her the bag of M&M's

"Haha, no, he is amazing really" she sighs and smiles, she looks genuinely happy

"Do you love Jay?" I ask, eating some M&M's as well

"Yes, I do" she smiles and throws a popcorn in my face

"Have you told him that?"

"No, I don't think he loves me back" she says with a sad smile

"One thing you should know about him, is that he doesn't really express his feelings. I think you've noticed that already. He loves you, but he's not sure enough that you love him back"

"Yeah, I noticed that. He's a bit of a closed book, huh? He seems like such a confident boy on the outside, but inside he isn't that confident, is he?"

"He's confident about his looks, but I don't know, I think he has a hard time believing that someone can love him for him" I softly smile

She smiles sadly again and I toss a popcorn towards her again.

"But tell me about the skinny dipping. What bet did you lose?" I say, grinning at her red cheeks

"Uh, we made a bet about you and Mason"

"What?" My eyes widen and I look at her like she has gone crazy

A bet about Mason and I? What the actual fudge.

"I thought that Mason didn't have the balls to kiss you, like a real kiss, not for a dare. However, Jay thought Mason did have the balls to kiss you"

My mouth forms an oh and it all makes sense now.

"So that's why he was smirking like crazy when Jake made me confess my feelings to Mason and when Mason kissed me. I thought it was kind of weird that he wasn't all big protective brother and stuff"

She chuckles softly.

"He asked me 357 times if I really wanted to"

Her eyes roll, but it's obvious that she enjoyed the moment.

"Did your first time hurt?" It's the question that's been dancing in my head the whole time. What? I'm just curious.

"For the first minute or so it did, but after that it didn't anymore. It depends though, Jay's big, but we don't know about Mason"