Red Dead Redemption II Preferences and Oneshots

Andrew Milton: Bargaining Chip

Andrew Milton X Female Reader

Summary: Agent Milton and Agent Ross capture the reader and hold them hostage while waiting for the gang to come to rescue them. During the waiting time, Milton will be extremely close and flirt with the reader but in the end when the gang arrives, the reader is alone and the agents have already left.

Word Count: 2330

So, things hadn't exactly gone as planned. You had been in town on your own, which you do all the time. You often go on jobs on your own so this was suppose to be your day off, just find something in town to do for a while before getting back to the camp. But that was where you ran into Agent Milton and Agent Ross. You had tried to get out of there before they saw you but it was too late, they chased you down and arrested you. Well, they didn't really arrest you, the bound your hands and took you hostage. That's more accurate.

"Miss L/N" Agent Milton smiled as he stood in front of you and Agent Ross tied your hands behind your back, you didn't respond, you just glared at him. "We were just talking about you, well you and your friends. We are going to give you a choice, Miss, you can either tell us where your camp is located or you can come with us and we will use you as a bargaining chip" Milton explained as if he had any concern for your well being, like he was actually trying to do you a favour. You weren't stupid.

"Or you could let me go and nobody back at camp has to know that you two manhandled me out of town" you shrugged, raising an eyebrow at him, knowing that he understood the threat behind your words.

"Negotiation with your friends it is. I hope that you are important to them" Agent Milton smiled again before turning around and mounting a small wagon. 

"Fuck you" you spat at his back. Agent Ross tied the bindings on your wrist a little too tightly 'by accident' after the words left your mouth, making you wince and trash against him. He apologised sarcastically before pushing you towards the wagon. He practically threw you down in the back before climbing on as well, keeping a gun aimed at you as you all road away from the town.

Eventually you arrived to an old, abandoned, barn where they decided to hold up. They pulled you off of the wagon and dragged you inside before throwing you to the floor at the back wall. You huffed before lifting yourself up and leaning back against the barn wall, glaring at your captors. They talked among themselves before Ross picked up a rifle and walked out of the barn, you assumed that he was on look out while Milton was suppose to watch you.  

"They are going to come and get me, y'know" you told him, keeping your glare hard on him. 

"We are counting on it. The van der Linde gang has a 'no man left behind' policy. Something that I can actually respect about you and your friends" Agent Milton nodded as he crouched down in front of you. 

"It's called loyalty, something we take very seriously" you rolled your eyes. Was it really that hard to understand that you all defended each other because you cared about each other?

"And that's why you won't tell us anything about Dutch van der Linde?" he asked, tilting his head to the side. 

"Look at that, you aren't as stupid as you look" you smiled, sarcastically sweet.

"I really don't understand it, Miss L/N. Just tell me what I need to know and I let you walk away. We will protect you until we have dealt with the rest of the gang, after that you can walk free and do anything with your life. You can start again without the threat of the law coming after you, why won't you take this opportunity?" Milton asked, he was genuinely lost about why you wouldn't save yourself here. He was offering you freedom and you were turning it down with a smile and without a care in the world.