The third zodiac was unnecessary. I'm adding those scenarios here, so this will be continued.
Who first met you inside the woods and did they decide to keep you or kill you?
Aries: Kate The Chaser - Kill
Taurus: Bloody Painter - Keep
Gemini: Clockwork - Keep
Cancer: Judge Angels - Kill
Leo: BEN Drowned - Keep
Virgo: Lulu - Kill
Libra: Laughing Jack - Keep
Scorpio: Nightmare Ally - Kill
Sagittarius: Puppeteer - Keep
Capricorn: Ticci-Toby - Kill
Aquarius: Eyeless Jack - Keep
Pisces: Jeff The Killer - Keep