Dead Again - Jeff The Killer x Reader

Phase 1

It's been 3 days since the 'flashlight' incident.

I was now in the living room, along with 10 other people, including Jeff and Toby.

They were on either side of me and I was in the middle.

We had all taken a vote and it ended up being 8-2, with Charlottes Web winning.

It was in the middle of the movie when Jeff suddenly screamed.

Loud.

And high pitched.

Like a little girl.

He jumped onto the back of the couch, leaning against the wall.

"What the fuck?!" I yelled, glaring at him.

He pointed at the carpet beneath the coffee table.

"There's nothing there? What, are you afraid of rugs?!" He pursed his lips and pointed again, more dramatically this time.

That's when I saw possibly the biggest spider in the world.

"AH SHIT WHAT THE FUCK." I jumped up next to him, grabbing onto him like my life depended on it.

Toby looked at the spider, then up to us.

"T-that's a ba-baby spider, you p-uss—sies." He stomped on the spider then sat back down on the couch.

The rest of the pastas in the room just looked at us, and unpaused the movie.

I slowly climbed back down, Jeff following me.

I still had a firm grip on him, as the shock hadn't worn off.

"That bitch was huge! Did you see that fucker's legs?!" I whisper-yelled to Jeff.

"I know! And Twitchy just stomped that shit into the carpet!" Jeff whispered back.

"Fucking psychos." We both muttered.

———

We continued watching the movie, and by the end I was a sobbing mess.

"Why- why the fuck... would they do that to me?! Look at me! I'm a whole ass mess!" I sobbed, grabbing Toby by the shoulders and shaking him.

Toby just laughed and shook his head.

"I-I'm pret-ty sure you-you're th-e only one cryi-ing." He twitched.

The rest of the pastas in the room slowly got up and left one by one, cleaning up their messes so Slender didn't get mad at us.

I saw that none of them were crying like I was.

Sure the ones without masks may look a little sad, but they weren't sobbing.

The ones with masks, you just couldn't tell.

I looked over at Jeff and saw he was out, even though I was literally yelling just 5 seconds go.

Toby winked at me and looked between Jeff and I.

"Nope. I'll leave him down here. This dudes pissed when he wakes up at a normal time, no way I'm waking him up now." I said.

"G-goodnight (Y/N)." Toby looked at me with a smirk.

"Night Toby, love you." I rolled my eyes.

"Love y-ou t-too." He got up and walked back upstairs.

I glanced at Jeff and smiled a bit.

"He looks fucking stupid." I laughed to myself.

You know he looks cute, (Y/N), you can't fool yourself.