Red Dead Redemption II Preferences and Oneshots

Eagle Flies: The Good Fight

Eagle Flies X Female Reader

Summary: After meeting Eagle Flies and Rains Fall and agreeing to help them, you and Eagle Flies grow close, you even try to convince him to stop fighting an unwinnable war.

Word Count: 3300

You first met Eagle Flies at the Mayor's party. You didn't really want to be there, you were only there because Dutch asked you go with them. So, you were walking around the party, trying to 'make friends' as Dutch put it.

Somehow, you had managed to walk right into someone. You weren't looking where you were going and you were lost in your own little world, so you walked right into somebody's chest. He caught you by your shoulders and held you at arms length, steadying you on your feet again.

Well, that was embarrassing.

You looked up at the man, who you would later learn was called Eagle Flies, and apologised profusely. The man assured you that it was alright and even apologised himself. He instantly knew that you didn't belong here, you were different to the others, but why? Who were you?

You couldn't help but notice that he seemed on edge, he was definitely out of place, he even seemed angry. In fact, it was obvious that he despised everyone at this party. You couldn't help but wonder why.

You never got to learn his name before you had to return to Dutch and he had to return to the older man he was with. You just assumed that you would never see him again.

You couldn't deny that he was handsome but it wasn't like you had much of a conversation, you were sure you would forget about each other pretty soon.

-----

You and Arthur were walking together through Saint Denis when Arthur apparently recognised a man. "Hey, do I know you?" Arthur asked as you both approached the man, who was standing with two other men.

"I believe we've met" the man nodded.

"We have?" Arthur asked, failing to recall where they had seen each other before.

"At that ghastly party" the man reminded him. You thought back to the party and then looked at the two other men, you remembered the younger one. He was the man that you walked into at that party! You didn't know whether you should be embarrassed about walking into him or strangely happy to see him again.

"Oh, Evelyn Miller?" Arthur asked, recalling the man's name.

"Unfortunately so, Mr?" Evelyn Miller paused, holding his hand out towards Arthur.

"Arthur Morgan, at least sometimes" Arthur muttered a little before shaking Miller's hand.

"And Miss?" Mr Miller turned to you.

"Y/N L/N, most of the time" you smiled and shook his hand politely.

"Can I say something rude?" Miller asked as he let go of your hand and turned to Arthur.

"Sure" Arthur nodded, wondering where this was going.

"The mayor thinks you robbed him. To be clear, he wasn't very upset about it. He rather liked you" Mr Miller told him.

"Okay..." Arthur hummed, now you were confused as well.

"Do you...well, I mean to say...can you steal things?" Miller asked, clearly a little nervous about asking such a question.

"Is there a reason you're asking me to incriminate myself, Mr Miller?" Arthur asked, you couldn't help but be curious as well.

"Well, I'm sorry. Have you met? This is Rains Fall, a great chief, and his son, Eagle Flies" Miller introduced you to the other two men, you finally got a name for the man that you ran into.