Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

Spooky Scary Spiders

Thank you very much to AnimeDweeb on Quotev for requesting this scenario! Enjoy~

Jeff the Killer:

"Eww a spider." You said, staring down uneasily at the giant arachnid on the sidewalk. Jeff glanced down, and to your horror he carefully picked it right up. Backing up, you immediately began to regret speaking. You knew what he was going to do, his back was to you and he was just staring at it between his fingers. Oh lord have mercy on you, please don't-

With a yelp, you spun around and ran away full speed the second Jeff started turning around, which ended up being a good idea since he immediately chased after you cackling evilly. "GET AWAY FROM ME DON'T YOU DARE!" You screamed, already running out of breath. You knew he was a lot faster and you wouldn't be able to outrun him, you were just hoping at this point he'd show some mercy . . .

Ben Drowned:

To no one's surprise, you and Ben were high off your asses again. The two of you were sitting on your bedroom floor and staring into space while listening to music, when you suddenly spotted a spider crawling towards you. You stared at it emotionlessly, you were pretty scared of spiders but at the moment you were relaxed- oh hell no it's way too close. With a squeal, you jumped up and ran behind Ben, who was staring blankly at you in confusion. When you pointed to the spider now crawling towards his shoe, he laughed so hard it seemed he couldn't breathe.

"Stop laughing." You whined, making him snort.

Eyeless Jack:

You and Jack were walking peacefully through the forest again, when you gasped and stopped. "Oh no, look at that spider! Gosh, I hate spiders they're so-" You stopped when Jack reached forward and picked up the arachnid with his fingers, making you let go of his other hand and back up in fear he would throw it at you. But he didn't, instead he lifted up his mask, threw back his head, opened his mouth and-

"No!" You meant to smack the spider out of his hands and onto the ground, but by the time you saw him lowering the spider away from himself, you had already smacked his hand, making the spider fly into his mouth. After thirty seconds of hacking, coughing, and screaming he finally hacked up the spider. The whole walk home you apologized profusely to Jack, who begrudgingly forgave you after you gave him a few kisses.

Masky:

Tim was a lot more mischievous then you first anticipated. When you spotted a spider near your foot and screamed, you expected him to quickly crush it for you. Well, he kind of did. He grabbed a tissue and smashed it, but before he walked away he pretended to grab the spider and flick it at you, which obviously sent you into a panic. You jumped and ran away screaming, which made him chuckle and smirk happily.

Hoodie:

With a shriek, you jump up and run behind Brian, reaching for his hand. He looks at you confused, and you whimper. "There's a spider . . . it's really big, bigger then me!"

"That's not hard to achieve." He replied, walking towards it. You ignored his sass and watched with disgust as he picked it up and threw it outside.

"Thank you . . . I'm sorry." You squeaked, shyly hugging him. He rubbed your back comfortingly, making you smile.

Homicidal Liu/Sully:

"Liu! Get in here quick! Hurry!" You shouted. He rushed into the room, looking rather panicked, but his expression changed to annoyance when he saw you were pointing at a spider. "Please kill it." You whimpered, and he sighed. Liu quickly crushed the spider while Sully complained about you.

"We should go put it in their bed. No. Yes." You watched as he turned the corner, worriedly wondering if he was heading to your bedroom or your bathroom to flush down the spider.