Years after setting down different paths, a chance encounter causes the two formerly star-crossed lovers to return to the stage together. When the song is over, everything they thought quickly begins to shatter around them, leading Tim and Faith to reconsider their decisions in the past.

In a twist of fate, the chance encounter that set Tim and Faith in motion is derailed, changing their lives. Instead of becoming steadfast lovers, they're industry rivals, battling one another for a spot on the top of the chart. However, just as fate pulled them apart, it brings them together once more in ways some may even deem supernatural.

Four years of pain and fighting after their divorce has left them here... worn down, broken, and frankly, lost. Faith fights to move on, despite the feelings that will always linger for Tim. As she begins another relationship, Tim tries to get out of one. After Tim's stint in rehab, he and Sara begin to fray, leading Tim to start thinking about his previous relationships. Fate and deceit show their cards, forcing the two to face the unthinkable before it's too late.

It's been three years... Three years since what seemed like a fairytale came shattering down around them. Tim struggles to come to terms with the grounds of the divorce, and his fight against alcoholism, while Faith tries her best to move on into a foreign territory. Their children keep them tied together, requiring them to collide time after time, forcing them to wonder what could've been. Their history seems to continuously merge with the present, derailing their efforts to move on. After Faith is slated to walk down the isle to a lawyer, and possible candidate for senator, Tim decides to give it one last shot to repair their marriage, only to realize that what brings them together is what inevitably always seems to pull them apart.

Mack was like a father to Tim, taking him under his wing, offering him a job, and often keeping him out of trouble growing up. When a girl walks into Mack's shop one night, Tim's life is changed forever... Just as life begins to taste sweet, things take a turn for the worst, leaving Tim hospitalized, fighting his way to consciousness after a devastating car accident which should've killed them both.

On a rainy night, their car plummeted off an overpass, and onto the bustling highway below. For the moment, it seemed everything would be just fine, until Faith wakes up with believing it's 1987... The last thing she remembers is sitting along the river in Mississippi, watching the sunset and drinking iced tea with her fiancé, Rob... Waking up in Nashville with a complete stranger in the hospital, Faith tries to manage everything that is happening without going insane. But can she handle it?

I've been hiding these bruises from the press and paparazzi for years. Surprisingly, they still have no clue about the drunken raids that take place behind our closed doors. All the nights I've cried, curled up in a corner while he passes out peacefully in bed... All the nights I've struggled to breathe because of him throwing me down like a rag doll... All the nights I've had to keep quiet for the sake of our kids' sanity and our public appearance. But now all that work is for nothing... All the work is dismissed in one foul swoop when he slaps me on stage, in front of twenty thousand adoring fans. I told myself I wouldn't let it go this far...

Everything she knew was beginning to fade, mimicking the sheet of paper she wrote her wedding vows on, and the dried bouquet of pink roses inside of the secretary. The only man she's ever loved, the only man she's ever given her heart to, has vanished, leaving only a note behind. Left with a four and three year old, Faith is left to fend for herself. With a career shooting toward the stars, she has been left to choose not only between her career and her family, but also between letting the public know, or completely avoid the subject. That's when 'They' walk into her life... Her high school sweetheart, a music executive, and a music journalist. To add on to the stress, her lost love reappears, in an attempt to apologize. But how could she choose between old and new love? Could she afford the pain of a new love? Or would she forget it, to face the old sting?

I would've never guessed that a day fishing at the pond would lead to years of chaos and turmoil, after a little blonde girl falls in, not knowing who to swim... I'm supposed to protect her, as I've always done. But things are getting harder, leaving her more vulnerable than I would like. It's doesn't help that the world seems to be against her...

One night... That was all it took to turn their world upside down. Tim and Audrey are left to choose what to do after a night demolishes all they thought they knew. The only flaw is, they both want to take different paths -- one leading to a long, complicated future together, and another leading to a simple future apart. Left with their choices, the two follow their own path, and Audrey hits the road, leaving to attend college in Memphis, as planned. Tim travels to Jacksonville, pursuing a law degree. Tim heads back home after he is finished with schooling, lead a successful yet lonely life, while Audrey is trapped in a relationship that is anything but healthy. Due to her mother's insisting, Audrey comes home to stay with her mother for a while, evidently running into Tim. So do all roads truly lead back home?