Alyssa thought she was done with the studio. The world thought they were done with Joey Drew as well. But, as it turns out, the past is never done with you. Nearly three years after her trip to Philadelphia, Lys is now in college, is near the top of her class, and has good friends. Her dreams about the studio and what happened there never seemed to bother her anyway. When Alyssa finishes her midterms, she decides to visit an old friend in New York for her break. Near the end of the trip, however, the pair discovers just how much the past can come back to you, when they find something in the heart of the city. Something that they know shouldn't be there. Alyssa's visit to New York soon turns into a mission to protect her companions from an old enemy from her past, who she learns may not be done with her just yet. The sequel to The Creator Lied To Us!