Shadows In The Same Light
  • Reads 6
  • Votes 3
  • Parts 3
  • Time 17m
  • Reads 6
  • Votes 3
  • Parts 3
  • Time 17m
Ongoing, First published Jan 28
Mattheo Riddle and Theodore Nott have always been best friends, the perfect partners in crime who rule Slytherin with sharp tongues, charm, and an uncanny ability to get whatever they want. Whether it's outsmarting professors, winning duels, or leaving a trail of broken hearts, they play the game better than anyone else.

But in their fifth year, the lines between their games and their feelings begin to blur. Beneath the confident smirks and reckless antics, unspoken truths linger. When jealousy and tension rise, Mattheo and Theo must confront the biggest game of all: risking their friendship for something more. In the shadows of the Dark Lord's rising power, they'll discover that the hardest battles aren't fought with wands-but with hearts.
All Rights Reserved
Sign up to add Shadows In The Same Light to your library and receive updates
or
#58haryypotter
Content Guidelines
You may also like
~Twisted Loyalties~ Matheo Riddle x OC x Theodore Nott by 3lueey
33 parts Ongoing Mature
In a world where power defines worth, Eris Potter-the sister of the famed Boy Who Lived-has always been nothing. Born without magic, she grew up in her brother's shadow, destined to live as a forgotten girl in the wizarding world. But everything changes when two boys from the wrong side of darkness find her, their eyes burning with dangerous intrigue. Matheo Riddle and Theodore Nott-sons of the darkest lineage, offer her a choice: join them in the shadows or face certain death. Inexplicably drawn to their twisted allure, Eris makes a decision that seals her fate. She steps into their world, discovering an ancient power hidden within her, one that could reshape the magical realm. With the weight of dark magic upon her, she begins to carve out a new identity- one feared by even the darkest wizards. As Eris is thrust deeper into this intoxicating life, the lines between loyalty, desire, and danger blur. In this dark romance with a "why choose" twist, Eris navigates her growing power and the intense connection she shares with Matheo and Theo. She must prove her worth not only to them but to the dark forces watching her every move. As the tension between the three intensifies, one thing becomes clear: the girl who was once nothing will either rise to be one of the most feared witches in history, or fall into eternal darkness. Her heart and fate belong to the shadows now, and in this game, there is no turning back. Matheo riddle x Oc x Theodore Nott if you don't like gayness leave!! Hogwarts War is here Uhhh, semi slow burn, just very confused humans trying to love each other #1 matheoriddle (12/11/24) #1 hogwarts fanfic ( 11/25/24) #1 matheo (12/5/24)
You may also like
Slide 1 of 9
Trapped in the Past | Mattheo Riddle x Male OC cover
Obsidian Whispers cover
Cutting Corners | T N ✔︎ cover
𝐆𝐀𝐌𝐄   ||  Riddle Brothers cover
~Twisted Loyalties~ Matheo Riddle x OC x Theodore Nott cover
𝐏𝐎𝐈𝐒𝐎𝐍𝐎𝐔𝐒 | mattheo riddle cover
Lilith cover
Hoax Lies || Mattheo Riddle cover
Sold to the Devil | M.R | +18 | English version | 𝖋𝖎𝖓𝖎𝖘𝖍𝖊𝖉 cover

Trapped in the Past | Mattheo Riddle x Male OC

15 parts Ongoing Mature

Ethan Potter never expected his sixth year at Hogwarts to be easy-not after the heartbreak of his fifth-year romance with Mattheo Riddle. A messy breakup left him isolated, watching as their shared friend group chose Mattheo's side. Now, with old wounds still fresh, Ethan braces himself for a year of awkward silences and stolen glances. But when a magical mishap locks them in a classroom overnight, the walls between them start to crumble. As laughter replaces bitterness and familiarity sparks old feelings, Ethan wonders-can they ever be more than friends again? Or has too much damage been done for love to find its way back?