Serial Killers In Love (EJ x Jeff Fanfic)

Chapter 1: Play Time With Sally

Jeff's POV:

I started to wake up and got up from my bed to walk around. Right as I was leaving my room I saw a note on my door as I was shutting it. The note said:

Dear Jeff,
As you may notice we are not here right now because we all went on a mission except for Sally, so you will have to babysit her for some hours until we return. You're probably mad at us but it's your fault for sleeping in late. Hope you have a great time with Sally!
Sincerely Slenderman.

I crumbled the paper in my hand and threw it 'That damn mannequin looking bitch!' I was pissed but who wouldn't be am I right?!? They could have at least waken me up or something. But why didn't they? Eh who knows I don't know what they're thinking. I started to walk down the hall thinking to myself until suddenly Sally popped out of the corner trying to scare me.

"Hello Mr.Jeff!" She said in a excited tone. 

"Heya kid!" I say while picking her up and putting her on my shoulders.

We both laugh at the same time. Sally is a pretty energetic kid and loves to play dress up or have tea parties. She's also sweet and kind, she's like a little sister to me.  

"Mr.Jeff I'm hungry!" Sally whined. "I guess I could make you something to eat." I say as I'm walking towards the kitchen. 

"What would you like kid?" I asked while putting Sally down on top of the counter. "Hmm...can you make cookies or cupcakes?" Sally asked perking up.

"Let's see I guess I could try." I said shrugging and very unsure. "Yes!" Sally shouted getting off of the counter and jumping up and down.

-Skip to 2 hours cus I'm lazy-

After a few hours we were able to make some cupcakes. We tried making cookies but they got burned and turned into a disaster.  But soon after awhile we were able to make cupcakes I believe we made almost 30 of them. Me and Sally both ate 2 cupcakes and saved the rest for the others. We were going to go watch TV but Sally asked:

"Hey Mr.Jeff can we play dress up together?" I start to hesitate a little bit and answered with a "Maybe." She just looked at me with this pouting face which I hate to see. I sighed. "Ok fine." 

She jumped up with excitement and I smiled a little then she grabbed my wrist, and dragged me to her room. On the way there she told me how the outfit would fit me and why she picked it out for me. As we enter the room she goes towards her closet and took out the clothes she wanted me to wear. My face started to blush from embarrassment because she pulled out one of Jack's hoodies, a white skirt and knee high socks. 

"There is no way I'm wearing that!" I say trying to leave but Sally stopped me. "You have to!" She pouted.

"And if I don't?" I questioned her. "Then I'll tell Slendy that you were the worst babysitter and that you were being mean to me!" She shouted with a hmph at the end and crossed her arms.  'Dang it!' I really don't like it when Slender gets mad.

"Ok fine I'll wear it, give it to me." I sighed. She handed me the clothes and I went into the bathroom to change.  After I changed I looked into the tall mirror Sally has in her room. The hoodie was a bit big and went a little over the skirt showing about an inch or two of the skirt. The sleeves went up to the palm of my hands and the socks went a little below my knee caps. As I was looking at myself in amazement Sally came up behind me and put a flower crown of black roses on my head. I looked at her and she was smiling then I glanced at my reflection and started to blush out of embarrassment. 

"See Mr.Jeff you are pretty!" She shouted with joy and excitement. "How'd you get one of Jacks's hoodies?" I asked curiously. 

"A magician never tell their secrets!" She said with pride. "Oh really now?" I questioned. She just looked at me and smiled. "I'm going to change into my outfit now." She said grabbing a dress and going into the bathroom. 

As she was changing I couldn't help but look at the mirror and twirl around. I smiled a little and started to sniff the hoodie. 'It smells like Jack!'  Wait did I just sniff his hoodie?!? I just blushed at the thought. I'm weird aren't I but I've always been weird. Not gonna lie I have feelings for Jack but I ain't going to tell anyone or him and luckily no one has figured it out. Then Sally came out of the room wearing a little puffy, glittery pink dress with flowers on it and the sleeves were down showing her shoulders.

"How do I look Mr.Jeff?" She asked smiling. I couldn't help but smile and say "Like a a princess!" She started to giggle and jump up and down. 

I was going to take the hoodie off but then I noticed something outside of Sally's window. I went closer to it and looked outside my eyes widen, It was the other pastas! I quickly shut the curtain hoping they didn't see me which most likely they didn't but still it's gonna be embarrassing if they saw me in this. Sally got very excited and started to clap her hands while jumping up and down for like the 100th time. 

"They're back!" She shouted starting to leave the room. "I'm going to tell everyone what you're wearing!" She shouted running off.

I heard Slenderman yell "We're back!" I also heard all of the others talking.

I started to run after Sally trying to keep up with her so she wouldn't say anything but she was to fast. She was already running down the stars as I was almost to them. 

"Slendy you're here!" She said while hugging his leg. "Where's Jeff, Sally?" I hear him ask her. All of the others probably were asking the same thing. 

I tried to slow down so I could sneak past the stairs to go to my room but then I tripped over my own foot and a loud Thud! went through the house. "Ow..." I groan in pain. 

"Jeff is that you?" I heard Slenderman ask. I started to panic and replied with a "Who else would it be!?!" I heard Sally laugh I swear if she says anything-oh wait Slender would beat my ass if I did anything. 

"He's just embarrassed!" Sally said joyfully. "Why would he be embarrassed?" Ben asked. I hear everyone questioning while Sally just giggled.

"Sally if you say anything I will never play dress up with you-!" I had just realized what I was saying and covered my mouth with my hands.

I heard them laughing downstairs. "Wait you actually played dress up with her!?!" Toby asked while yelling.

"Can we see?" Jane and Clockwork asked. "No way!" I yelled back. I felt myself blushing now as I got up off the ground. I put my hands in the hoodie's pocket. 

"C'mon on Mr.Jeff please show them my beautiful masterpiece!" Sally pouted. "Ugh! Fine!" I complained. I could hear all the others talking while Sally giggled. I started to walk down the rest of the hall and stopped at the top of the staircase while blushing. Everyone was looking at me in amazement. 

"Now that you guys have seen me I'm going to my room now." I scolded while walking away.