Grayson:
You guys met at a party a friend of yours was throwing. You were never a big fan of parties and your friends had disappeared, so you were alone. As you were wondering around the house looking for them, you bumped into Grayson and you guys ended up talking all night and eventually exchanged numbers at the end of the night.
Ethan:
You guys met at a local coffee shop that was right down the street from where you lived. After getting your coffee you bumped into him causing you to spill your drink all over him. You felt bad and kept offering to buy him a new shirt, but he'd just chuckle and say that it was fine. After talking for a bit and getting to know each other he eventually walked you home.
--
Sorry it these are lame, but please comment what other types of preferences you think I should make and I will :)