Sage Parsons is your every day awkward teenage girl with unexplainable stage fright and an unadmitted crush on her best friend's twin brother. So when her best friend Wrenlee begs her to come with her family caroling for Christmas (along with her brother), Sage gives it a hard pass. Except then Nicky asks and her now pretty obvious crush makes her agree. As Sage fights both her feelings and her anxiety, she wonders if maybe this Christmas will come with some unexpected gifts that are a little harder to wrap in paper and place under a tree.