Years ago, years and years ago, Sophia Anderson had fallen in love with Arthur Morgan. But he never felt the same for her until she ran for sixteen years, never looking back at the man she loved or the men who raised her as their own. Fast forward, she meets up with the Van Der Linde gang once again. Them running from the law, and Sophia running from them. She bumps into them one night on her way home, four of them trying to rob her and Dutch is skeptical about letting her back in, especially since she just held Bill Williamson at gunpoint. Will Sophia be able to rekindle the love she had for Arthur Morgan? Or will this be the end?