'My sister visits each year with a new boy friend. But this boyfriend seems different...cute even.' Zariah's older sister Kristine visits her with a new boyfriend. It's a rough start for Zariah and Kristine's boyfriend, but soon enough they become friends. They secretly in their hearts become more than just friends and don't know if it's right. Kristine's boyfriend does Zariah a big favor by pretending to be Zariah's boyfriend in front of Mia the popular girl. In spin the bottle, the bottle points at Zariah and Kristine's boyfriend. Zariah feels like if she kisses him she would be cheating, so instead she doesn't and takes a dare. The dare is for her to dye her hair half pink and half black, to humiliate her. She does it and her chorus teacher thinks Zariah went too far for the musical Dollhouse by Melanie Martinez. At a library shop, Zariah and Antonio(Kristine's boyfriend) are chatting, when Zariah tells him how she feels and thinks that she can't go on with the fake relationship and should stop before Kristine finds out. They give each other a kiss, but Mia is filming them! What is going to happen to Zariah? Is Kristine going to freak and break up with Antonio? Well, read to find out.