What if Spottedleaf had not died? What if Spottedleaf still lived in StarClan? Everybody knows the Erin's wanted Spottedleaf to go just so Firestar wouldn't have to choose which she-cat to be with in StarClan. But now? ~ The characters in this book does not belong to me. This is a fanfiction. Contains ONE spoiler from the book Apprentice's Quest. It is mentioned in the first chapter. ~ Welcome! Sandstorm lovers, Spottedleaf lovers, Sandstorm haters, Spottedleaf haters... Join here and enjoy my story! :)