What if Lucy was never asked by Cana to be her partner for the S class trials and Cana had someone else with her and Lucy was left in Fairytail till the end of the S class trials What if Natsu comes back and finds his best friend 6 years older then him but he still loves her even if he doesn't realize it ( ok so I see Lucy as 1 year younger then Natsu until this obviously) What if Lucy has a secret and does not want anyone to know until levy finds out what will everyone else think and she is worried what Natsu will say What if Lucy had spent every weekend looking for everyone ( Ok so even without Lucy let's just say no one died cough cough Wendy Natsu cough cough when he fell and when she was hit with the attack from hadis cough cough and Natsu still has the lightning flam dragon mode )