The first time that Matt Meese and Mallory Everton meet is less than ideal. Matt makes a mistake that might guarantee that the two of them will never be friends. However, they are forced to be co-workers. Mal can't find it in herself to forgive Matt, and even starts to hate him more as they continue to act in sketches together. Matt, however, finds himself falling in love with the spunky, kind-hearted girl. The rest of the Studio C cast plots and schemes to get the two of them together, but nothing seems to work. And then one day, something happens that reminds the Matt and Mallory of the first time they met, and it will either tear them apart forever or give them new hope.