creepypasta headcanons because yes

music tastes (ALL HEADCANONS)

Jeff the killer:
prob like main genre would be like emo pop punk as well as screamo stuff and occasional metal

bands include:
my chemical romance
pierce the veil
black veil brides
the used
set it off
metallica
scorpions
slipknot

BEN drowned:
video game ost's definitely, occasionally dabbles in pop punk because of jeff

games/franchises that he'd listen to the ost's from:
legend of zelda games obv
undertale and deltarune
sonic games
minecraft

Eyeless jack:
probably wouldn't listen to much music, but I imagine him listening to phonk, but also listen to a bit of everything

artists:
freddie dredd
ramirez
kordhell
INTERWORLD
DVRST

Laughing jack:
nursery rhymes to lure his victims, other than that, not much

Jane the killer:
very girly pop music, think ayesha erotica, megan thee stallion, nicki minaj, doja cat yk (maybe the occasional mitski/girl in red but very rarely)

artists:
ayesha erotica
megan thee stallion
nicki minaj
doja cat
ice spice
cardi B
ariana grande

Slenderman:
classical music like beethoven, other than that not much, but splendor got him into harry styles 💀💀💀 also clair du lune

artists:
beethoven
harry styles
franz lizst
frederic chopin

Nina the killer:
very very girly pop music, she's a swiftie, pop girlie forever and in love with harry styles (pre her 2021 remake) also boy bands

artists:
taylor swift
harry styles
ariana grande
dua lipa
sza
lana del rey
katy perry
beyoncé
one direction
5sos
olivia rodrigo

Clockwork:
metal. straight up metal. cannot stand anything too soft, some rock/grunge music too, also bit of nu metal

bands:
metallica
slipknot
slayer
megadeth
linkin park
deftones
nirvana
ac/dc
the smashing pumpkins
alice in chains

Ticci toby:
mother mother tbh, call me cringe or a poser but he just gives off the vibes, also for genre it would mainly be modern rock like p!atd

bands:
mother mother
the neighborhood
the 1975
panic! at the disco
arctic monkeys

Masky/timothy:
can't stand most music, I can't picture him listening to music, I honestly think he would hate it

Hoodie/brian:
same thing with Tim but he can probably slightly tolerate it but has no actual favorite bands or anything

Sally:
HUGEEEE theatre kid, she loves it, but occasionally dabbles in melanie martinez or jazmin bean and marina

musicals and artists:
hamilton
mamma mia
beetlejuice
six
waitress
melanie martinez
marina
jazmin bean
poppy

Homicidal liu:
emo emo emo emo emo emo if anything he's the one who passed it down to jeff, lots of the same bands as jeff also screamo is something jeff inherited from him too

bands:
my chemical romance
fall out boy
jimmy eat world
paramore
panic! at the disco
blink-182
asking alexandria
all time low
sleeping with sirens

that's it for now, this was fun to make tbh! hope whoever finds this will enjoy it