The First Scream

Chapter 15

Before I start this chapter, I'm gonna ask you guys for help. If any of you know how to make a cover, I would like you to make me one!! The girl I have in this cover picture is just some girl I found on Google images 😂 so, if you can make a cover,please use the image above(or any image of Marley Rose/Melissa Benoist), and a picture of Noah/John. Thank you all for your help!

Carly's POV

The annual carnival is in town, and this year, its a little bitter sweet. Jake and I went together last year because no one else would ride the big roller coasters with us. Im excited and dreading it at the same time.

Any ways, I'm sitting in the backseat of Noah's car. Audrey is telling us about experiences with the killer this morning.

"No one will ever forgive you" Written in blood on her mirror "13 dead" Written on her ceiling.

"Tyler, Nina, Rachel, Riley, My Dad, Will--"

Noah cuts me off, "The guard at Brandon's cell, Grayson, Sheriff Hudson, Jake, Eddie, and..."

"Piper. But that's still one short of 13" Audrey is obviously panicking.

"He's trying to get in your head." I reassure her

"Trying? Carly, he's in there." She tells me.

"You gotta take your power back! You know? As long as you have this secret, the killer owns you." Noah says.

"You're right, okay? You're right! I'm trapped! But if Emma finds out What I did, I might as well be dead" Audrey lowers her voice.

"Tell Emma the truth and you'll be free" Noah tells her. She tenses her jaw, opening the passenger door. I follow behind her and give her a short hug.

"You're gonna be ok. You're not gonna be number 13, he's just messing with you" I pull from our hug, keeping my hands on her shoulders.

She nods quickly and walks towards the school. Noah joins my said and puts his arm over my shoulders. We follow close behind Audrey, on our way to physics class.

Noah, Audrey, and I take a seat next to each other. Zoe comes and sits next to Audrey, Stavo sits next to me.

"Is anyone else having a hard time studying physics right now?" Noah asks us. We all exchange glances before I nod a bit

"Do you think Ms. Lang really just fell? Or was she pushed?" Zoe asks Noah. Here we go, que the rant.

Stavo speaks up, surprising me, "It doesn't fit the killers profile. Leaving a teacher at the bottoms of the stairs where she landed... this guys too talented for that. There's no staging, no big reveal, like.. Actually, no need to speculate. You were there. Right Audrey?" 

Stavo is almost as good at that as Noah is. They should be sidekicks or something. The sheriffs hot son and the no longer virgin. Sounds like the best crime fighting duo to me. The intercom comes on, drawing me away from my thoughts.

"Hello students, this is Mayor Maddox. Many of your parents have called with concerns about the impending Lakewood Days Carnival. Your safety is our primary concern, but what we will not do... is miss this towns 100th birthday"

The bell then rings, and everyone gathers their things. I no longer pay attention to the intercom, but follow behind Noah and Audrey, next to Stavo.

"Eager to move on, a wounded and misguided town concocts a flimsy excuse to celebrate, which in turn instigates yet another round of bloodshed." Noah stops walking.

"I mean, hasn't anybody seen My Bloody Valentine or The Prowler?"

"Uh, I have not seen The Prowler." I speak up

"Doesn't end well for anybody" Stavo tells me. See what I mean? Perfect duo!