Object Cringe Opinions.(OCO)

Firey and Leafy

They're both bad in my opinion, and the ship is a mixed feeling in my opinion. So let's go through this weird and complicated ship storyline...

Season 1 (BFDI):
This is the only season where Firey had actual lines and some personality shown on camera, for example his story is him and Coiny slap each other for the fact is they hate each other for some reason, it wasn't ever explained why they even hated each other in the first place. I'm not even sure why Firey won in the first place, I guess it was that relationship with Leafy? I don't know but He won, so he brought everyone except for the ship, I guess you could say he burnt the ship! In all seriousness though, when Leafy was upset that she didn't get into the island she paid the Announcer to get Dream Island all to herself. Which for some reason magically made  Dream Island disappear, when Leafy was supposed to own the island. Then when the cast realizes that Leafy stole the island they give her the death penalty, which Firey saves Leafy, it's because he realizes he didn't want the island and wanted her, which makes the ship alive again and then they go off to the sunset ending the season. This made a lot of people ship the ship, so much fanart of it, so much stories and etc. but there's next season that kills it again.
Bonus stuff: I thought Leafy was okay but was way too nice.

Season 2 (BFDIA):
Let's start at the beginning, where again Leafy's getting chased by the cast because they want the island, but once again it would be useless because the ship was still a thing. Wait a minute where's Firey in the scene when Leafy was being chased? No where to be found, that means ether that he must of lost memory theory, the puffball theory, he cared but not as much anymore.

The first fan theory is that he crashed onto the mountain and somehow loss his memory of Leafy, this is supported because of episode 4 Firey said "who's Leafy?" she becomes saddened before being smashed in the head of the hammer. The fandom still supports it by the fact she is Yoyle berry metal colored because she ate nothing but yoyle berrys which is the only food in her land I suppose, but besides that then there's no other evidence, because when Leafy comes back in Bfb, Firey seemly knows her again.

Next theory that I made up, He cared but not much as much anymore.
There's evidence to back this up, but not too much so don't complain in the comments.
This is supported by the fact that the map was the last of Firey, he then try to forget Leafy which is why he didn't remembered Leafy possibly. BFDIA got cancelled because the cast was chasing Firey Speakerbox for something, it wasn't explained but it could be proof why Donut broke Firey Speakerbox. That's pretty much all of the evidence I got, well the last theory is pretty good.

The last fan theory is the Puffball theory, what the Puffball theory is that Puffball may have hypnotized Firey into not somewhat remembering Leafy for a bit or and to hate Leafy later on. This theory could be the best reasoning and it makes the most sense out of three theories.
This could be proven by the fact by the fandom is maybe Firey threw the Goiky canal map towards Leafy before being hypnotized to an last effort to save Leafy. This also goes with the fact that Firey doesn't remember Leafy when she gets smashed with the hammer. I support the Puffball theory very well in fact I put more of the Puffball theory in the later seasons, but enough of that let's go onto Season 3.

Season 3 (IDFB):
Firey got trapped and Leafy kinda just wants everyone dead for some reason, possibly invading her home land or the fact that they want to kill her first for stealing the island or there's the possibility when Puffball was eliminated, Firey remembered Leafy and recovered her but Freesmart saw what happened and then everyone chased Fireafy (Yes I did used the ship name to get this story shorter XD) again, once again Firey sacrifice himself for Leafy so she can get away, the cast of Bfdi didn't like that and remembered that Firey was afraid of heights so they put him at the highest building, which is right where Freesmart is living/hanging around.
That's all I gotta say for season 3, it only got one single episode, well time for the final season of mixed feelings of a ship storyline.

Season 4(BFB):
The final season possibly, and the only thing I could say that Firey remembers Leafy because in her elimination he smiled, so he probably doesn't care anymore because of Loser or Puffball, but mostly Loser because of the fact most of the cast loves Loser and besides Puffball is hypnotizing Fries.

Conclusion:
Like I said there's things in this ship that makes sense but however there are problems with it. Which is why I'm not shipping it, but now you know why people defend it, do you ship it or don't ship it? Write it down in the comments below.