If You Had To Choose(Bertholdt x Reader x Reiner)

Just Another Day?

  Come morning, Bertholdt had woken before the sleeping girl. When she woke, Bertholdt had already been to his house. He changed into a clean outfit when there, along with any other preparations he needed.

  Y/N drowsily walked into the kitchen, already dressed and ready as was her routine. She sat at the table, wearing a pair of black jeans and a long sleeved and striped black and red shirt with a v-neck. 

"You cook?" She sleepily answered.

  Bertholdt set down two plates. Each had two slices of spam and two waffles with an adequate amount of syrup. He nodded shyly.

  Y/N took a bite of the spam, smiling, "Its delicious." She mumbled. Bertholdt nervously rubbed the back of his neck and mumbled, "I tried..."

  Soon both had finished, Y/N stood and grabbed her bag. Bertholdt did the same. The two two walking out, it was way earlier than Y/N was used to but, figured it was when Bertholdt left. Instead of leaving at 8:30, they were leaving at 7:00.

  Once the two arrived, Bertholdt excused himself without a single reason. Y/N shrugged it off however, seeing as she just met the guy. Y/N sat on the outside blue tables. She sighed, bored out of her mind.

  A blonde walked forward, "Hello there. Why are you sitting alone?" The male asked, sitting beside her.

  Y/N looked up, he had short blonde hair, pale gold eyes, and glasses.

"Oh uh... Just got here earlier than usual..." Y/N mumbled.

"I'm Zeke. Who are you?" He questioned.

"Y/N. Y/N L/N." Y/N answered with a smile.

  Zeke hummed, "You're that new kid in my brother's English class. Eren Yeager, ring a bell?"

"Uh... Yeah. I think. Woah... You two seem nothing alike." She muttered.

"Different mothers. Some things just don't work out the way we plan, right?" Zeke spoke in a calm, almost confident voice yet not inherently friendly like Reiner's voice was.

"Yeah... I actually lost my parents at a young age..." She mentioned.

  Zeke set a hand on her shoulder, "I know how that must feel. I only had my father, my mother had died due to a reckless drunk." He explained, the ghost of a smile on his face. It was companied by the look of sorrow in his gaze.

  Y/N pulled the 6'0 male into a hug, the blonde's body tensed as he had not thought the female would hug him. Both unaware of the jealous glare that Reiner had. He had come early just to hang around her.

  Reiner walked over, "Y/N!" He exclaimed happily.

  She turned to face him, the muscular male pulled her into a tight embrace. Flipping Zeke off behind her back. Zeke simply shook his head and walked away.

"I have to go to class early!" He called out the lie with ease.

  Y/N pulled away, looking up at Reiner who beamed down at her.

"Early, aren't we?" He mumbled.

"Yeah..." Y/N sheepishly mumbled.

"Well, are you free today? My parents will be out of town and I'm bored as can be." Reiner asked.

"Oh uh... Sure?" Y/N mumbled.

  Bertholdt walked up as the bell rang, Reiner went his merry way while Bertholdt and Y/N went to the classroom.

  Y/N sat down, sighing. "Bertholdt..." She mumbled, "What are your hobbies? I'm curious."

  Bertholdt looked to her, his cheeks dusted with pink as he got out his homework, "I-I like art... And m-music... I play the v-violin..." He stated, "What about you?"

"Well... I like writing and singing." Y/N whispered shyly.

  Bertholdt smiled, unaware that class had started. Y/N began focusing on Mr. Zacharias's every word. In hopes that he would explain it better than yesterday.

  When the bell rang, Y/N groaned and looked to Bertholdt. Who had packed his stuff.

"Hey... Tomorrow. Study group?" Y/N offered.

  Bertholdt smiled and nodded before leaving. She left soon after.

  Throughout the day, she had only gotten more and more excited for after school. Hanging out with an attractive guy like Reiner. Then there was the study group with Bertholdt that she had to plan. As she walked towards P.E. she thought about who she could invite.

"Zeke... Maybe? Reiner too... Eren for sure. Mikasa and Armin. I think that's it..." She mumbled to herself as she got dressed out.

  Y/N stood on her number, watching Shadis as he called out exercises. She had little trouble with the jumping jacks, sit-ups, squats, and even lounges. However with the push-ups and running... She seemed mediocre at best.

  She watched Reiner do them so easily, her gaze drifting down to his own ass which was impressive. Y/N's face went red. When she finished, Reiner ran up to her. He had been running beside her since her face went red.

"You need water?" He asked in mock concern.

"I-I-'m fine!" She squeaked out as the bell rang.