Aries - Slenderman or Jane Everlasting
Taurus - Ben drowned or Alice Madness
Gemini - Sally Or Jeff the killer
Cancer - Ticci Toby or Stalker Nana (My OC)
Leo - Bloody painter or Judge Angels
Virgo - Masky or Darkness
Libra - Dr Smiley or Nurse Ann
Scorpio - Kagekao or Suicide Sadie
Sagittarius - Ej or Nina the killer
Capricorn - Laughing Jack or Laughing Jill
Aquarius - Darkiplier or Smile the stalker(Second OC)
Pisces - Antisepticeye or Burned Alice (Third OC)
Sorry if you don't like it
