I'm Not A Bad Person|Eyeless Jack

17

"y/n?" I hear someone call out to me. I don't answer. I stay still and hold my breath. I have even been here a day yet. I got here early in the morning and the sun is just starting to set.

"Listen, I don't know where you are, but..." they pause "I've been ignoring you for a reason. You like Ej- not me. I needed to get this off my chest."

"Toby?" I jump down from the tree branch. I'm only standing a few feet away from him. I look to my right and see a few other creepypastas walking towards us.

"Listen, I'm sor-" I'm cut off by Toby smashing his lips into mine. I try to push away but he pins me to the tree.

"WHAT THE HELL Y/N!" I hear someone scream. Toby backs away and I see Jack standing there.

"I-It's not my fault!" I plead. He shakes his head and walk away. I look at the other pastas as they also walk back to the mansion.

"That was a lie darling- prick." Toby walks away. I slide down the tree bringing my knees up to my chest. I let myself cry and cry.

"IM NOT A BAD PERSON!" I scream while crying. I let my eyes close and feel my body go limp. What's going on?

—Jacks pov—

"What's going on!" I walk down the stairs to see Slender shaking his head.

"Your girlfriend broke tobys arm."

"How did you-"

"It's obvious child." Slender walks out the door me following short behind. I see the proxies (including masky this time) walking towards the woods.

"Let's go." I look up at slender, he nods in approval.

"Why did she run off?"

"Don't know, would've been easier if she just stayed, I wasn't going to yell at her." He states. As we get closer I see two people. The closer I get the more I see their faces.
Y/n and Toby

"WHAT THE HELL Y/N!" I stare at her.

"I-It's not my fault." I shake my head and feel the tears fall down my cheek behind my mask. I turn and walk back towards the mansion.

"Wait Jack!" I hear Rouge run up to me, "Are you okay?"

"N-no." I choke on my words. I feel her pull me into a hug. Killers are portrayed as cold heartless people- but we can learn to feel, to love.

"She wasn't worth it." She rubs my back and holds me while I cry. "Let's get home."

-next day-

I wake up and am in my bed. "You're awake." I hear Slenders voice.

"Yup." I lay back down and take a deep breath.

"I don't think it was her fault."

"How can you be so sure?" I scoff.

"Well let's see! She broke Tobys arm, Toby has been ignoring y/n, and y/n loves you. Considering her past she would never cheat on you. Whenever you two were hanging out I would sometimes spy on you, she would always be freaking out. She loves you Jack. Talk to her."

"Where is she?" I get out of bed throwing on my hoodie and pants.

"I don't know. She never came home. She might still be in the woods." I nod and grab my shoes then run out the door.