Kinsey, Alea, and Jayna are on a case in New York about vampires working with werewolves to kill people who find out what they are doing. While they are the case they are wondering if Lilly, Mike, and Gabe are okay. But they also meet Dean and Sam Winchester and they see Cas again. Now with their help they can solve this case and stop Lucifer from taking Kinsey and taking over Heaven, Hell, and the World. And they need to stop Ruby, Madison, and Nicky with a little of help from Shadow and Francis. Will or will not Kinsey fall in love with Dean, Alea fall in love with Sam, Jayna fall in love with Cas, and Francis fall in love with Shadow wait and see.