~ You're Taught To Be Good, But You Learn To Be Bad ~ Finn Wolfhard X Reader

She's Too Soft

Finn's POV

Y/n had become rather comfortable with the group. She had even started opening up about herself, saying things even I hadn't known about her. This was the most I'd ever seen her smile.

After a while she started to become tired, she had taken a seat next to me and fallen asleep in my arms. It was now 12:30 A.M and I knew she'd flip out at me if I let her stay the night. I gently rubbed her arm, trying to wake her. Her beautiful e/c eyes fluttered open.

"Finn?" She muttered, sleepily.

"C'mon hotness, I gotta get you home." She shook her head in disapproval. "Do you wanna stay?"

"Yes..." She whined, burying her face in my side, trying to fall back asleep.

"Okay. Goodnight, Hotness." She fell asleep again. After about another half hour of her sleeping on me, I began to feel cramped and climbed out from underneath her. Gently replacing my lap with a pillow.

I immediately headed outdoors, where the group was. They had originally left to give Y/n and I some "alone time", little did they know we were going to spend it talking about music, and family, and other sentimental crap I usually try to avoid. I didn't mind it though... I liked doing things with Y/n. She made everything interesting. I walked out and took a seat on the edge of the building's wall, letting my legs hang hundreds of feet above the ground.

"Have fun?" Gaten smirked.

"Shut the hell up, we just talked."

"Mhm." Millie hummed.

"Mhm, what? I'm not kidding. We just talked." I replied, turning to face them.

"Wait, seriously?" Gaten asked. I nodded my head. "Dude, what the hell? You never "just talk", what happened?!"

"Nothing." I shrugged.

"Did you at least make a move?" Sadie interjected. I shook my head 'no'. "Why the hell not?" She asked.

"Because she's a nice girl, she deserves better than that."

"She's turning you soft!" Caleb barked.

"She is not!" I barked back.

"I think you deserve better than some good girl, who got into one fight." Sadie critiqued.

"Yeah, Sadie's right," Gaten announced. "You deserve a bad bitch, Finn. Not someone like her, she's too soft."

"I'm gonna make her into the bad bitch, you're all talking about. That was the plan, we needed a new recruit and as the leader, I get to decide so who and when. Now quit riding my ass and let me do my job!" I burst. They all quieted, and after a while, they tried to strike up a new conversation. I suddenly felt very antisocial and headed out to my car. I needed to get out of there.  

Time Skip >> Next Morning (Your POV)

I opened my tired eyes to find I was still at Finn's warehouse. Half asleep I called out his name, no answer... I rubbed my eyes, trying to clear my blurred vision.

"He bailed." A familiar voice said. I looked over to see Carl on another couch, watching me like a hawk.

"What? Where'd he go?" I asked in a sleepy haze. Carl just shrugged. "Do you know when he'll be back?"

"No way to tell." He smirked.

"What time is it?"

"Almost ten o'clock." He replied, looking at me curiously.