Sagittarius- Eyeless jack
Scorpio- Jeff the killer
Pisces-hoodie
Aries- BEN DROWNED
Aquarius- puppeteer
Taurus- bloody painter
Libra- laughing jack
Leo- Jason the toy maker
Gemini- ticci toby
Cancer- Kagekao
Capricorn- slenderman
Virgo- Masky
Mariablodgett gave me this idea for this chapter p.s. sorry if spelt your name wrong