Colby Brock x Reader

Part 1

October 2018

( Y/N POV )

i was sitting on the couch at brennan's house when i heard a violent knock at the door i knew exactly who it was i was scared to open it , he knew my secert , he knew i loved both him and Brennen but Brennen didn't know . I live at the mansion with Colby Sam and Jake and Corey and Aaron but i was with Brennen . He trusted me not to cheat on him I thought I trusted myself but some mornings i would find myself in Colby's bed and I didn't regret it.

Brennen opened the door and Colby walked in , it looked like he had been crying , he looked at me and i looked at him I could see in the corner on my eye Brennen staring at me looking confused and worried he didn't know anything about what was going on. I didn't know what to do I looked down I could feel my face getting hot as if i was about to cry I looked up to Brennen asking "whats wrong on?" , "either you tell him or i will!" Colby violently said , "COLBY IT'S NOT YOUR PLACE TO TELL YOU SAID I COULD CHOOSE WHEN!" I yelled. "Y/N WHATS GOING ON ,SOMEONE TELL ME" brennen yelled. It was silent for a couple of seconds i felt tears coming out of my eyes knowing what Colby was about to do. "Y/N is cheating on you with me Colby said. Brennen looked at me "this isn't true your lying she would never cheat on me right y/n he's lying right" i didn't know what to say i was trying to talk but no words were coming out ,  "Im sorry" i said trying not to cry

well who do you love brennen said . "both of you" i said slowly . NO YOU HAVE TO CHOOSE! Colby yelled as he looked like he was about to cry. i looked at him "you know i cant" i said , Y/N CHOOSE brennen yelled . both boys were looking at me waiting for me to choose . i couldn't hurt either of them i didn't know what to do

Y/N please choose it will be better if we just knew colby softly said. i began to cry even more both boys looked hurt..

ok fine i said slowly I choose...