𝓤𝓷𝓮𝔁𝓹𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓮𝓭 𝓒𝓸𝓷𝓷𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓲𝓸𝓷 ~ Jeff the Killer X Reader

7 Minutes in Heaven pt2

Your POV:

We sat on my bed kind of awkwardly for a minute before I realised it was my go.

"Umm... truth or dare... Toby!" I said.

"T-Truth." He said.

"Hmm... if you had the choice to hang out with Sarah for a whole day would you?" I asked with a smile.

"... W-Well yeah of co-course I would, not l-like we haven't hung ou-out all day before remember." He said as he scratched his head.

"Mmm true." I said with a shrug.

"Truth or d-dare... Jeff?" Toby asked.

"Truth." Said Jeff.

Sarah leaned over to Toby and whispered in his ear.

"Were y-you and Y/N kiss-kissing in the wardrobe?" He asked as Sarah smiled at me.

*Really Sarah? What does she have like a 6th sense for this shit or something?! I wonder what Jeff will say.* I thought as I looked up at Jeff.

"Yeah, so what if we did? You gotta problem with it?" He ask as he tightened his grip on me slightly.

Sarah suddenly shot up and grabbed my arm, she pulled me away from Jeff and towards the door.

"Oi! Where are you going?!" Asked Jeff surprised.

"Snacks! We totally forgot about snacks! Can't hang out and not have snacks!" Said Sarah as she pulled me out of the room and down the stairs to the kitchen.

"Sarah! Ouch! What are you doing?" I asked as I realised what arm she had ahold of.

"Ouch? I barely touched you... you said ouch in the wardrobe too." Said Sarah as she pulled the oversized sleeve up my arm exposing a slightly bloodstained white cloth. "What the fuck?! What happened?"

"When you pushed me and Jeff into the wardrobe you forgot he still had his knife in his pocket." I said pulling my sleeve back down.

"Oops... sorry." She apologised.

"All good it was just a small cut, nothing major." I smiled.

"Well now that I know your ok." She said hitting my other arm playfully. "Jeff kissed you!"

"Yeah... what about it?" I asked nervously as I started gathering some snacks.

"Pff! WhAt AbOuT iT?" She said trying to mimic me. "He KISSED you! That's wHaT!"

I blushed slightly before shaking my head softly and walking back to the room.

"Hey, we got the snacks." I said as I walked in with a smile.

I put the snacks down on the bed and as I went to sit down, Jeff grabbed me and I was back in his lap again. Sarah walked in with a giggle as she watched me get dragged back into Jeff's arms and she jumped on the bed next to Toby.

"Ok, my turn... truth or dare Sarah?" Jeff asked.

"Dare~" She said excitedly.

"I dare you to do 7 minutes in heaven with Toby." He said with a mischievous smile.

"Run out of good ideas have you? You gotta go stealing my AMAZING ideas." She laughed.

"Nope... it's payback time!" He laughed.

Jeff sat me on the bed carefully as he moved Sarah and Toby towards my smaller wardrobe, he opened the door, pushed them inside and before he locked the door he took their phones.

"Have fun~" He cooed with a smirk.

Toby's POV:

Jeff pushed us towards the smallest wardrobe in Y/N's room and locked us inside.

"Have fun~" He said softly.

"Th-This isn't fair... he p-put us in a smaller sp-space." I said to Sarah.

"Yeah... sorry I'll try to move back as far as I can." She said as she shifted her feet and accidentally stepped on my toes.

"Y-You know I c-can't feel that, r-right?" I laughed.

"I know that... just thought you'd want as much space as possible." She said nervously.

"You n-nervous?" I teased.

"What? No, why would I be nervous?" She said defensively.

"Really? You su-sure seem nervous." I laughed.

"... Oh do I?" She said quietly as she moved closer to me.

"W-Whoa... I was j-just teasing." I said as I tried to move back and head butted the wardrobe wall.

"Now who's nervous?" She giggled.

Jeff's POV:

"Everything seems to be going smoothly in there." Y/N giggled.

"Yeah." I laughed.

I put my arm around Y/N's shoulders, she wrapped her arms around my waist and cuddled into me.

"How long are we gonna leave them in there for?" She asked.

"I don't know... however long we feel like I guess." I said as I played with her hair.

Toby's POV:

We sat in the wardrobe quietly for a bit before Sarah gave out a big sigh.

"What do you wanna do?" She asked as she laid her head on my shoulder.

"Get out... I-it's getting hot and u-uncomfortable." I said as I lay my head on hers.

"Well move around your probably in an awkward position." She said as she started to shift around.

I followed her instructions and tried to move but my foot got caught and I fell forward pinning Sarah against the back wall of the wardrobe. My head was in the crook of her neck and her arms were around my waist.

"Are you ok?! She asked concerned.

I could feel my face getting hotter so I lifted it to look at what I could see of her face in the dark.

"Y-Yeah... I'm f-fine." I said nervously.

I don't know what came over me but lately I've felt something every time I'm with her, something that I haven't felt for a long time... but this time it's slightly different. As I looked down at her I could faintly see that she was still wearing my goggles and I smiled to myself as I felt myself slowly get closer and closer to her. Suddenly before I knew what was happening I kissed her, I shot back surprised at my actions but she caught my hand and pulled me back.

"I-I-I'm sorry." I stammered as I felt my face grow even more hot.

"Huh?... What for?" She asked.

My eyes widened at her question as she looked up at me.

"I-I should've a-asked if you wa-wanted to do th-that." I ticked nervously.

She giggled a bit before she tightened her grip on my hand slightly.

"You don't have to ask silly, is that how you feel... about me?" She asked quietly.

"... Y-Yes... I like y-you Sarah." I said as I scratched the back of my neck.

"I feel the same way." She said happily.

She slid her arms around my neck and hugged me as she buried her face in the crook of my neck. I lifted her head with my finger and kissed her again.

"Your m-mine now, right?" I asked her.

"Of course!" She giggled and kissed me again.