Stranger Things Cast Preferences

What You Steal Of Theirs

Finn
His vinyls
-you don't have a single one of your own that you haven't listened to so you steal some of his
-you accidentally pop one on the record player when he's over.
-oops?
-"Y/N is that my vinyl?"

Caleb
His hoodies
-"Y/N have you seen my yellow hoodie?"
-"nope, haven't seen it"
-you've accumulated a collection to the point where he has to ask your mom to pull them out of your laundry

Noah
His go-go squeezes
-"Y/N! Did you seriously eat the last one?!"
-he makes you buy more for him
-"this time you better not steal anymore of them"
-"But Noah, I didn't steal them. I borrowed them"
-he doesn't really care though

Gaten
dUSTINS NEW HAT
-rip old hat you will be missed
-he took it home from set and you keep stealing
-he sees a picture of you wearing it on Instagram
-"@gatenmatarazzo um... is that my hat?"

Sadie
Her vegan cookbooks (we stan a vegan queen)
-you made her a 3 course meal for your anniversary but forgot to give them back
-So now you just randomly cook up vegan meals
-she knows you're using it
>but she doesn't care

Millie
Her nail polish
-lets be honest, there's probably a salons worth of nail polishes in her room
-you were hanging out and swatching them
-then you found a good one and stuck it in your bag home
-"omg Y/N is that my nail polish?!"
-insists you keep it