Back to You

37

Quinn closed the apartment door and joined Finn on the couch. She looked at Rachel and Beth.

"Hey, Beth." Rachel said. "Will you show me your room?"

"Okay!" Beth nodded as she took Rachel's hand and dragged her away.

"You wanna tell me what you're doing here?" Quinn asked. "I mean, you guys are always welcome here, but-"

"Rachel told me what you told her." Finn said. "At the bar. About Ally."

"I was drunk. Rachel was drunk." Quinn said. "Just forget it."

"I wasn't drunk." Finn shook his head. "And you told me to make sure Ally didn't drive Puck home."

Quinn looked at Finn.

"At first I didn't think anything of it." Finn said. "Then Rachel told me what you said and she's pretty sure that Ally was drinking."

Quinn bit her lip.

"But Puck said she's pregnant." Finn stated.

"Yeah, he told me she was throwing up this morning." Quinn explained. "I guess he thought it was morning sickness, but..."

"It was probably a hangover." Finn noted.

Quinn nodded slowly. "I told Jake not to tell Puck."

"You told Jake about this, too?" Finn asked.

"I said a lot of things last night that I shouldn't have." Quinn responded. "To Rachel, to Puck, to Jake."

"Well, as someone who was in a similar situation six years ago, I think we should tell him." Finn stated. "I could be the one to do it."

"He's not gonna believe any of us." Quinn shook her head.

"He might." Finn argued. "We can't just sit around with this and not do anything."

"All we have to do is make sure the wedding doesn't happen." Quinn told Finn. "Jake already said if he has to jump in and object, he will."

"So what do I do?" Finn wondered.

"You can agree to be his best man and keep your mouth shut about this." Quinn stated. "We don't even know if she's lying or just being irresponsible or if we even saw what we think we saw."

"I don't think this is a good idea." Finn said.

"If you tell him, it'll only push him further away from you and me and the rest of his friends and closer to Ally." Quinn told Finn. "You and I know Puck, and once he gets something in his head..."

"I know." Finn sighed as Rachel and Beth returned.