Creepypastalovestory Stories

32 Stories

The Hateful Love We Have (JeffxJane) by SomberClubs
#1
The Hateful Love We Have (JeffxJan...by Somber Clubs
It has been four years since the 'accident' that created Jeff the Killer, Jane the Killer, and Homicidal Lui. Jeff has had a weight of guilt on his concupiscence ever si...
The Unforgivable and the Unforgettable by _-_JeffTheKiller_-_
#2
The Unforgivable and the Unforgett...by Jëffrëy VïçïøüsKïllër Wøøds
read about the love life of a crazed, insane murder and the one she falls for...Jeffrey Woods.
The Garden  by MaskyLemon
#5
The Garden by Gay._.Men
(Yes back after 2-3 years yass deleted my other books from embarrassment but anyways) This story is about masky and hoodie and there difficult times throughout the mansi...
Timeless Gold by PenguinGirl1246
#6
Timeless Goldby PenguinGirl1246
She fell in love with with him like the rain, fast and unexpectedly. May Withers is a 23 year old woman who suffers a major 'still-feels-like-a-teenager' cold case...
ReMEmbER Me?¿ (Ticci Toby X Reader) by ssreader17
#7
ReMEmbER Me?¿ (Ticci Toby X Reader)by ssreader17
sorry for anyone who is bad with sad things, y/f/n y/l/n, (your fist name and last name) She was just a normal girl, she has one lover Katie,(Srry she a female plz no ha...
✘ ⌜K̶e̶e̶p̶ I̶t̶ A̶ S̶e̶c̶r̶e̶t̶⌟ ✘ *Creepypasta Love story* by EnchantedMem0riez
#8
✘ ⌜K̶e̶e̶p̶ I̶t̶ A̶ S̶e̶c̶r̶e̶t̶⌟...by EnchantedMem0riez
It happened 2 years ago. 2 years ago that I snapped. Lost all my sanity. It was all my parents fault. I always get beaten up or yelled at. And for no reason!. I decided...
Slender's Very First Proxy by Veilenian
#9
Slender's Very First Proxyby Raze Morales
Masky faced toby with pure hatred in his eyes " You will never replace her " he growled stomping away Creepy pasta x OC ...... pwease read my story ;_; Ther...
The Darkest Gift by SkyCrevan
#10
The Darkest Giftby Sky Crevan
Raven Edmer is just your average twenty one year old. Expect for a few recent and not so recent events. When she was only three months of age her real parents gave her u...
Jeff The Killer x reader-Love at First Fight  by smoshluv
#11
Jeff The Killer x reader-Love at F...by smoshluv
A bloody brilliant love story about your favorate Killer, Jeff. He tried to kill you but he just couldn't do it you were a beauty to his beast. The love of his life
Raised By Wolves [A Creepypasta Fanfic] by ShadowOfAMonster
#12
Raised By Wolves [A Creepypasta Fa...by Divine
The one in which teenaged Allison Black almost dies, burns down a building and almost dies again, is kidnapped by a faceless apparition, and falls in love with Toby Erin...
Trapped A Jeff The Killer Romance. by xCAMxZOMBIExLOVEx
#13
Trapped A Jeff The Killer Romance.by xCAMxZOMBIExLOVEx
Ok so this is my first fanfiction I'm kinda scare that it won't be good enough so if you like it maybe you could "vote, comment, and share" for me. It would me...
Fell In Love with Human *Ticci Toby X Emily*REBOOT by yammy-25
#14
Fell In Love with Human *Ticci Tob...by Yammy Rose L.Williams
Emily have a hard life to her everything leave her alone doesn't matter Her Old friend died name Toby Rogers but never change the Life of Emily Wilson FIND OUT WHAT G...
Jeff x OC by AmiKatKpopLover
#15
Jeff x OCby Katie Star
Bomi lives a sad life. She is a lonely human? Or is she....... How is she connected to the pastas, and Jeff, Read, and find out.
Tics and Tricks (Ticci Toby x Reader) by MCthefriendlysheep
#16
Tics and Tricks (Ticci Toby x Read...by Toko Fukawa
You should figure it out by the title, a prank gone wrong on your friends. you soon meet a dude named Toby and he's like a Ticcing Time bomb! Updated every Friday #21 Cr...
ticci toby love story by Toby_The_Kat
#17
ticci toby love storyby Toby_The_Kat
ticci Toby has a friend and he likes her. her name is Frances. there are multiple sex scenes in it, I'll give you a warning about that.
Even Crazies Can Love (creepypasta story) by TaylaJ3343
#19
Even Crazies Can Love (creepypasta...by TaylaJ3343
"baby, baby please don't do this!" my mother screamed when she realized what im going to do. "remember, when you used to ask me what i wanted to be when I...
It All Began With A Whisper (Jeff The Killer X Reader) by Mick3yIsRandom
#20
It All Began With A Whisper (Jeff...by Mick3yIsRandom
It was a cold night. November 12... Thursday... 11:58 pm, young girl named Y/N was walking alone in the cold streets of her home town... She heard something