Tobyxben Stories

Refine by tag:

12 Stories

Im not afraid to fall in love with you (Toby x Ben) by Crazy_angel_45
Im not afraid to fall in love with...by Eclipse
Toby x Ben. (Not a super popular ship buuuttttt. I think it will do it anyway). *sexual content* kinda. Soo. If you arent 13+ dont read. Thank you. *swears* and this is...
Glass Closet (Ticcitoby X Ben Drowned) DISCONTINUED by flowerrface
Glass Closet (Ticcitoby X Ben Drow...by zach
-🐀 This story is discontinued and I probably won't be working on it again
Ben x Toby by _rayhackett_
Ben x Tobyby ~•Rayhackett•~
Sorry in this au toby doesn't tic
TIcci Toby X Ben Drowned  by howboutyastop
TIcci Toby X Ben Drowned by Nobody Knows
I just need an outlet for the things in my life. I have alot of trauma. THIS IS A ROUGHT DRAFT JOURNAL I'm 22 in treatment and I really hate where I'm at in life.
The Rainy Night ( Ticci Toby x Ben Drowned) by ZombieBtch
The Rainy Night ( Ticci Toby x Ben...by Kacey
Ben is scared of the rain so he goes to Toby's room and Toby let's him sleep next to him [I'm bad at descriptions] (Warnings: Bad Grammer, Bad Spelling, Probably bad sto...
Completed
Creepypasta roleplay by hamiltonfanupsessed1
Creepypasta roleplayby hamiltonfanupsessed1
Includes- ????️‍????gay????️‍???? lesbians possession depression suicidal thoughts emoness and werewolf ben and were cat Toby
Toby Loves Ben? by YouMayCallMeJunie
Toby Loves Ben?by Juniii
Toby is not sure if he "loves" ben Once he did something wrong that he regretted and can't get out of his head he just wants ben more and more. But there is s...
Love Letters (A Creepypasta Love Story) by sidthekitten
Love Letters (A Creepypasta Love S...by Sydney
BEN and Jeff and Toby and LJ X BEN and Jeff and Toby and LJ. Also, Sally. But no Sally shipping. Basically.
Fate Brought us Back Together by EdwrdMustangismine
Fate Brought us Back Togetherby Boredom
It all started that day I might you. You where the one who understood me. Is this really goodbye! (So this is my first YAOI fanfic so here it goes. I notice not a lot of...