Fading Darkness || Original Rewrite || вxв ⚣

:꒰ Chapter 10 ꒱:

He looked at the male leaning into his hand hearing he loved him "Do you love me...Or do you love the idea of me, I...I don't think you'll ever truly love me, You see your past mate in me I think thats why you love me...And...I guess that's why I'm like this to you, Because I'll truly never be him and that upsets me..." He admitted, He leaned away prepared to get hit once more for saying something like this. He closed his eyes gripping at his wet fur on his knee waiting for the slash he probably would receive again.
Nightmare only sighed deeply and seemed a little hurt. "That's not why I wanted a chance with you. You two are different. You aren't him and you never will be. It would be an insult to both you and him to say you were the same. I wanted a chance with you to try and move on and love someone again. I don't mean to be obsessive over you but it's hard when it's been years since I've truly felt like I could love someone again."
FredBear opened his eyes slowly when he didn't feel a slash, He turned his head looking at him. "But...Everyone said you chose me just because I look like him and have his name...I don't mean to speak of him...I just can't help overthink it and I want to be able to tell you my feelings..." He said as he slowly got onto the males level getting into his wet lap as he sat down on it, nuzzling into his chest. "Maybe...Because I've never had someone want me so much I'm overthinking every little thing now...I'm sorry if it's irriating you, I can stop talking..." He told nuzzling his face into the boys wet fur sighing a bit again.
"That's just what they assumed... At least that's my guess. I never told them that it was the reason behind my choice. I chose you because you seemed so sweet and innocent. I... actually didn't know that you had the same name until I had decided to try and learn more about you. I overheard your name when you were talking with one of your coworkers. I saw the similarities but I had never truly thought that you were going to be the same. You're much too innocent compared to him. You were also, happier, it seems. I'll let you know this too... I had hurt him before as well. We weren't exactly the picture of the perfect couple. We fought a lot too but we still loved each other. Honest to God, I still don't think I deserved someone as forgiving as him. As well as I don't deserve someone as forgiving as you..." Nightmare continued, ears lowered a bit as he seemed slightly sad yet glad he was able to get some of his emotions about his loss out.
Fredbear listened to him looking at him when his ears went down, "I...I'm sorry to hear that but..." He said holding the males hand gently "I don't think I will ever forgive you what you've tried to do but...You seem different from earlier, I...I want to give you a chance but I'm scared." He told as he hugged him softly "I'm sorry...If I hurt you...Maybe you should get a private therapist and than maybe we can get somewhere..." He suggested before he leaned in kissing the males lips softly.
"I don't think therapy's going to be an option for me for some time since I'm going to be the biggest suspect to everyone in your disappearance from the diner. I mean; I'm already suspected by police for murder, so me being commonly seen where you worked would be a red flag to them. Besides, I don't know where to start looking at the moment. I know therapy is what is going to help me but I don't know where to start with it." Nightmare replied, shifting a bit and slightly flinching at the kiss. "I-I wouldn't, right now. My rut... I don't want to do anything to you right now." He then said, blushing lightly as he looked away. He likely needed some time to recollect himself and get over his small amount of sadness he felt at the moment.
The omega sighed feeling the flinch "You have a computer right? Look up some therapy videos it'll help you and you can talk to me about anything I'll be your personal somewhat therapist..." He told as he held the boys face close to his, "Nightmare...I...I want this...I want to make up, I want...I want to help you with your rut..." He told as he touched his chest in truth he wasn't doing this for his heat but he did feel bad for Nightmare that he wanted to forgive him for what he's done and see if he would treat him gently during this.
Nightmare stayed silent in a few good moments of hesitation. "...Are you really sure...? I.. I don't want to hurt you again." Nightmare was torn between his raging testosterone and high levels of hormones and his guilt. Along with the fact that Fredbear had outright admitted that he did want to do it again, he felt confused on whether he should do it or not. On one hand, yes, he wanted to, but on the other he feared being too rough on the omega and making him fear him again, making him want to shy away from the opportunity. "Just... be sure, okay? I don't want to hurt you anymore than I already have..."
The golden bear looked at the male as he listened, He stayed silent for a few minutes thinking about what he just offered truly...'If I do it with him...He may hurt me...But on the other hand if I do it with him, We may make up and I might truly figure out why I feel this way...What if he's right and I'm accepting he's my alpha...What about Bonnie?...' He thought as he looked down taking Nightmares hand softly. 'If...He's really now my alpha even by force...He can't hurt me forever right? Like Bonnie said I can't be afraid of alphas anymore, I need to be strong and get over it...' He told himself as he looked at him nodding softly "I...I want to get over this...It's gonna happen either way right? Either by force or by choice, I know your rut Is gonna increase and thats gonna make my heat worse to the point we feel like we're losing our minds and them we won't have any control of whether we want it or not...So...While we still have our minds straight a little bit, I think...I think we should do it, You can show your love to me...And I can figure out if...What I'm feeling is just my heat or if...I'm really accepting this..." He told him holding his hand close to his chest.
Nightmare gave a soft nod and sighed softly. "As you wish.." He said softly, taking a breath and moving himself into a better position with the golden bear. He was aligned with him, though wasn't going to start right away with penetration. First he gently pressed his lips to Fredbear's, wrapping his arms around his back slowly as he was trying to show his passion without his usual rough nature right away. He was slow and gentle, tender and sweet with his hands as every move was thought out for a few seconds. He was waiting for Fredbear's consent to enter him this time, moving his nose up and down his neck, up against his cheek and then up to his ear. Despite his inexperience with this in truth, he seemed to know what he was doing despite him being a little shyer about it because of previous regrets and guilt.
FredBear got comfortable on the alpha wrapping his arms around him softly, He was a bit nervous in it showed in his somewhat tense body and his ears that stood up...When he felt Nightmares lips against his he hesitated at first till he felt his gentle touch reassuring him it was gonna be okay, He leaned into the kiss returning it passionately...To be honest you could ask him where the passion came from and even he himself wouldn't be able to answer that question, When he felt the males nose go up to his neck and up to his cheek he couldn't help but let out a few cute moans from the touch he loved from Nightmare...He could tell the alpha was shy which was weird since he's only seen that in omegas before, After a few minutes of holding one another and reassuring each other not in words but by gentle touch he leaned to Nightmares ear. "I'm...I'm ready..." He whispered a bit shyly as he lifted himself up a bit from his lap so he could enter him easier. He had his face hidden in Nightmares neck you could say maybe cause he was embarrassed or shy by this.
Nightmare gave a small nod and used a bit of force to push into the omega, trying to be gentle but not having much experience with going so easy. He had to adjust himself, though slowly moved in and out, letting Fredbear adjust since he had become aware that he hadn't had sex, as far as he knew, for a very long time. Despite being a little rougher than the bunny had been, Nightmare was equally as loving during this. He took care with his movements and was keeping his pace slower than usual for the golden bear unless he'd be asked to speed up. He was still afraid of hurting him, but he was trying to push through that.
FredBear took a deep inhale in as he expected it to be a slam in but when it was more than rather gentle, He sighed out deeply wrapping his arms around Nightmare "A...Ah~" He let out a slight pained moan, He was way bigger than he thought he would be from not paying attention from when he was forced to take him...He leaned in, kissing on the males neck; giving soft love bites to him just to claim Nightmare back from when he gave him hickeys. After FredBear took time to adjust to Nightmare he nodded slowly. "You...Can go faster...I want you to enjoy yourself..." He told with an assuring voice as he kissed the alpha softly to distract himself. He'd be a lier if he said he didn't like the taste of Nightmares lips against his.
Nightmare sped up his pace a little bit, though still seemed slightly hesitant. He made a soft whimper at the bites, though it was from pleasure, not pain. He was still trying to keep himself from being too rough, though would eventually give up on that as he went harder, still cautious about his moves but knowing that Fredbear would make it clear if it began to be too much for him. He huffed a bit, aware that his rut seemed to be calming down a bit due to this.
FredBear gripped onto the males fur gently as he sped up, "Ug...Augh~ Ni...Nightmare~ I...I like...It...~" He said his body tensing a bit as his hole squeezed Nightmare from the new pace it wasn't used to since Bonnie took it a bit slow for the omegas first time...His pheromones began to suffocate the air once more as he enjoyed what he was feeling so much, his heat also agreed..
Nightmare got deep into the omega, brushing his nose up his neck and teasing him with a quick lick with his forked tongue on his golden fur. He knew passion and was showing it for Fredbear, keeping his pace once he knew that the other enjoyed it. The pheromones he was taking in were making his rut flare up again, but in this moment he truly didn't care. The larger male moaned a bit, feeling his body begin to slowly tense up with anticipation of eventual release with this continuing between them; The warm water, the storm outside, and the cute moans that came from Fredbear making it all even better.
FredBear let out a loud moan when he felt the male push in deeper, But it felt better when he felt the teasing on his neck...His eyes filled with tears but not bad tears more of pleasured love tears, "Ju..Just like that..." He cried out holding onto Nightmare, He looked out the window in the shower watching the beautiful storm...He felt so loved and cared for in this romantic moment in the shower, He heard the male moaning which turned FredBear on he sounded cute when he moaned making him want to make him moan more...He leaned down kissing the males chest licking his nipple a bit as his hips moved with the males pace as well wanting to pleasure the alpha.
Nightmare visibly tensed when Fredbear did this, making him bite his lip gently. He couldn't help it; His arousal made him extremely sensitive to such touch. Especially when it came from the omega he had considered his mate. He resisted his urges to moan again, wanting to make Fredbear work for it. He could tell the omega's intentions. Not to say he didn't want to give him what he wanted... He simply wished to make the golden bear work for it. Oh how he wanted to leave another hickey on his neck, though then again he didn't want him to feel hurt by it. So, he decided against it. He had already bitten him once to claim him and given him hickeys, so that would be enough. At least for now, unless he would beg for it...
FredBear pouted a bit when he didn't hear a moan but only the tension of the alpha inside of him, He leaned to the males neck slowly reaching his hands down to his tail rubbing it like a dick. "Mast...Master~ I wanna...I want your bites again...I want you to be rougher now" He said with a whiny beg tone of voice, As he said that he suddenly nibble around the males neck leaving patches of hickeys everywhere...Who knew the omega loved pain so much in sex... and with this Nightmare gave many whiny moans, not having been experienced with the pleasure being directed right back at him. His grip grew tight as he was tensed up, though his demeanor became more rough as it had been asked of him. He gave a few brief yet somewhat tight bites, leaving a few mildly bleeding hickeys. His neck was rather vulnerable while doing this, so with all the hickeys being given it was a great opportunity for Fredbear. Especially to get deep up the male's neck. It wouldn't take much more of this to make him release all the way up into Fredbear's womb.
FredBear got turned on more hearing the whines come from the scary alpha, When he felt the male speed up and become rougher he couldn't help but let out a bit loud moans of pleasure "Au...Augh!~ Mmh~" He let out as his ass was being pounded by the men underneath him, When he saw the males neck was wide open he leaned in biting down harshly around them leaving the same amount of bleeding hickeys as Nightmare was doing, He leaned near the curves of the males neck and shoulder was knowing it was the softest part of the human body he bit down just enough to mark the man as his...It'll be hard to retrace the mark which made it perfect so no other omega could mark him, Though he didn't realize what he had just done being clouded with pleasure in his head. As the bear felt himself get closer he looked at Nightmares eyes holding him close as he rode to help him cum inside, When he did indeed feel the similar yet harsher deeper liquid go inside him this time than the first he couldn't help but latch onto Nightmares lips as he released all over himself "Mmh~" He let out a small muffled moan inside the kiss, If he hadn't latched his lips to the alphas he would of probably screamed from the pleasure his body was going through right now...
Nightmare only broke the kiss once Fredbear's body had begun to calm down from the tensed pleasure, smiling softly as he pulled out and turned Fredbear towards the spray of the water so that the cum the omega had released would get washed off his golden fur. "Never expected you to be so happy during something like that." He said into Fredbear's ear softly, panting gently since he felt a little worn out. The entire experience had zapped his energy. Yet, he had no regrets. However, later on that might not be the same for his partner.