5SOS Preferences

#50: You like another band member

Luke: You had always had a crush on Calum ever since you met him.
Little did you know that Luke was secretly in love with you.
"Cal?" You asked stepping into his bedroom. "Oh hey Y/N" He replied smiling. "Can I tell you something?" You asked closing the door.
"Sure, rant away." Calum said jokingly.
You sat across from him on the bed, with your heart beating out of your chest. "Ok, well, I really like you. I've liked you ever since I met you three years ago. You're funny, kind, smart, humble, and loving. When you got a girlfriend last month, I cried myself to sleep every night. When I found out that she broke up with you, I felt so happy because I could have a chance with you. If you never want to talk to me ag-" You said but got cut off at that last part. Calum had leaned in and pressed his lips to yours.
You two had a full blown make out session, but not going too far.
Your lips attacked each other's hungrily. You buried a hand in Calum's hair, making him groan.

Luke's POV
I felt tears spring to my eyes at the terrible sight. Calum Hood and Y/N, two of my best friends, were eating each other's faces off. I cringed as Cal's hands traveled to her hair, slightly tugging on the strands.
Y/N groaned and started kissing Calum's neck. I decided I couldn't watch it anymore, so I left.
I've liked Y/N for so long.
I've been waiting to tell her that for three years. But now she's kissing Calum. Of course. Why would she like me? I thought once I was safely locked away in my bedroom.
She'll never love me.

Ashton(his POV): I felt a tear slip down my cheek as Y/N pressed her lips to Michael's, smiling. My heart shattered into a million pieces when Michael pulled her closer to him, wrapping his arms around her waist. I hope Y/N's happy with him.... But he will never love her as I much as I would. I thought bitterly as I walked away from the horrific scene.

Michael(His POV)
"I really like you Y/N" I said finishing my very long speech. "Michael, I'm so sorry, but I don't like you like that. You are one of the sweetest guys I know, and any girl would be extremely lucky to have you. Please don't beat yourself up over this. I can't have you do that. Just remember that we're still friends. And I like Ashton, sorry Mikey. We're still friends right?" She said softly.
My heart broke right then and there.
Of course it's not me.
Ashton is perfect for her.
"Yeah, of course" I said blinking back tears. "Be strong for me Mikey" She said before leaning over and kissing me on the cheek. Then she gave me a huge hug before walking out of my bedroom. Be strong , I thought.

Calum: "Do you think I should ask Luke out? I've always liked him, but I don't know if he likes me back" Y/N said.
"Luke really likes you, Y/N. Go ask him out, don't be scared" I said planting a fake smile on my face. Inside, I was breaking down. I've always liked Y/N, ever since I laid eyes on her. But she's always had a crush on Luke, my bandmates and one of my best friends. Luke was pretty good looking, to be honest. He has soft blonde hair that is styled into a quiff or is tucked back by a hat, ocean blue eyes that are very mesmerizing, soft pink lips that happened to be pierced, long legs, a cute laugh and very soft hands.
Oh and he has very broad shoulders.
What girl wouldn't like that?
"Thanks Cal, you're the best friend ever!" Y/N exclaimed hugging me.
Then she ran to Lukes room.
I stood outside the door, listening to their conversation.

This is how it went:

Luke: "Oh hey Y/N, what's up?"
Y/N: "I have something to tell you"
L: "Oh, ok, what is it?"
Y/N: "I like you Luke. Like a lot.
I love everything about you.
Your smile, hair, hands, everything.
If you don't like me back, it's ok"
L: "Are you kidding Y/N? I do like you.
I've liked you for a while. I just haven't worked up the courage to tell you until now. I like you, and I want you to be mine"

And then there was silence.
I felt tears well up in my eyes, knowing that there were probably making out. I slowly opened the door to make sure that my assumption was correct.
And sure enough, I was.
Luke had climbed on top of Y/N and his hands were exploring her body.
They were kissing like crazy, basically eating each other's faces off.
I quickly closed the door, running away from the sight. She will never love me, I thought sadly.

A/N: I'm sorry for the late updates!
I had an amazing time in FL with my family, going to the beach and eating at very good restaraunts. We also shopped and watched Jurassic World.
Anyway, I'm coming back today:)
Stay tuned for more exciting updates!
-Allie 🌸