Don't Judge A Book By It's Cover (Joshler)

D

Tyler's P.O.V

"Explain." Oh thank god. He's giving me this chance. I've realize that I can't explain why I want him to break up with Debby without mentioning the voices in my head.

'Are you outing us?'

'Are you crazy!? Josh could say something and he could send us...back there..' Yea, I know, but we can't keep this from him forever.

'Tyler's right Blurry. We have to tell him.'

'Fine.'

"Tyler?" I snap out of my thoughts. Whoa! When did he get so close? Josh was standing right in front of me. Both his hands were on my cheeks.

"I'll explain." I start. Josh removes his hand from my cheeks and I grab his hands and put them back. I lean into his touch. "I have these...voices in my head that I work with. They...they want to kill Debby unless you break up with her." I continue.

"Can't you stop them?" I shake my head 'no'.

"One of them is strong enough to take over my body. He's done it before. I have no control over it." I explain to him.

'I only took over cause it was important.' Yea stealing a stupid cheesecake was important.

'It was!'

"I don't know if I should believe you." Josh says. I remove his hands from my face.

"Fine, but if your precise world shows up dead somewhere don't come to me." I say before walking back to my cell. I shut the bars and lay down on my bed. Josh locks Brendon's door, but not mine. He leaves without saying a word. I feel tears start to prick my eyes.

"Well hasn't this just been a good morning." I say out loud to myself.

'That's it! She's dead! Killing her hurts him so it's a win win!'

'How dare he make you feel that way!'

"Shut up! Just shut up. Its not her fault that Josh loves her. They met first."

'But we can still take her down.'

"No! No we can't! When will you understand that Josh will hate us if we do that."

'I don't care! He hurt you, so I want to hurt him!"

"No. Don't hurt Josh. Let's just leave it and see how this'll play out. The only way I can have Josh now is if he decides to break up with Debby."

'You know what I realize?'

"What?"

'The itching stopped.'

"That's the best thing to happen to me so far."

Josh's P.O.V

Voices. It doesn't seem that crazy, but I just don't know. Its been about 30 minutes. Breakfast should be done by now. Tyler didn't get anything to eat. I should get something for him. I walk into the cafeteria to see that my inmates are sitting and chatting with each other. Good. I hope they didn't do anything while I was gone. I walk up to the lunch lady. Miss. Gravule.

"Hey you have anything without mushrooms?" I ask her.

"Why? You're not allergic to mushrooms." I don't have time for conversations. I just want to get this over with so I can go to my office and think.

"One of my inmates has an allergic reaction to it and he didn't get to eat anything." Miss. Gravule goes into the kitchen for a while before coming back with a some toast with avocado and some orange juice.

"Take this." She says handing me the tray.

"Thanks." I say before making my way to Tyler, but not before stopping by the others. "Don't think that just because I wouldn't be there that'll be your off day. Now get to the cell block." I order them.

"Is Tyler ok?" Scar asks. Has he grown an emotional attachment to Tyler already.

"He's fine." I say before walking away. The inmates get up from the table and follow me back to the cell block and I walk into Tyler's room while the others go to their rooms. Someone presses the button and all the doors open except Tyler's since his was already open. He's laying down facing the wall. "Eat this." Tyler turns around and looks up at me. No emotion on his face. How can he still look so cute? He takes the tray from me and looks away from me. I walk away from him and out of his cell. We can't ignore each other it wouldn't work.

"Hey Babyface you alright?" I hear Scar ask.

"I'm fine." Tyler replies. His voice monotone. No emotion present. I wince softly before opening the door and leaving. I trust the inmates know what to do. I walk to my office and sit at my table.

Why should I believe him? He's a psychopath. He'd obviously be good at lying and manipulation. He said he liked me and I do like him, but I've know Debby for 3 three years. We started dating a year after we met. I love her, but Tyler..I..Tyler is someone who I'd date if I met him first, but I didn't. Is it bad that I wish I did? Someone opens my door. Its Debby.

"Oh babe I'm glad you're here." Debby says as she walks in. Great just who I wanted to see. "I need you to watch my phone. Stupid officer Dantley doesn't want me to have it." Debby says as she rests her phone on the table.

"Yea I can do that." I say and smile at her.

"Thank you." She says before pecking me on the lips. Something feels wrong. Debby walks out and I sigh. What's wrong with me? Kissing my girlfriend of two years feels wrong to me. I take up Debby's phone and look through it. She has some boring games on her phone.

Ping

The message shows up on the screen so I can't help but read it.

Hey babe whatcha up to?

Uh its probably just her friend. Friends call each other babe sometimes. You can't blame me for being curious. I click the message and the chat shows up. I scroll up. They're very sexual friends. I scroll up until I see a picture. It was loading so I couldn't see it. Once it down load my heart stops. Who the fuck am I kidding!? Sexual friends my ass. She's cheating on me after all I've done for her!

Well I can't say that since I've technically cheated on her, but at least I said something about it. I've made Tyler basically hate me for nothing. I read a bit more of the messages just to make sure and yup she's cheating on me. She's been doing these things with this guy while she tells me to wait for marriage. What the hell. I exit out of the messages and put her phone down.

What am I going to do? I can't tell Tyler. If his voices are as dangerous as he makes them sound then they'll defiantly kill her. I may not like her like I use to, but that doesn't mean I want to kill her. Debby was my world and the only person I've ever loved like that. Well until Tyler. I mean I don't love Tyler, but I do like him and I want him so bad, but I don't know how or if I can deal with his murderous tendencies.

I may of fucked up ever having a relationship with Tyler. He finally found someone that he cared about and I said I didn't believe him. I half lied to him. I told him I love her when I don't. Anymore.

Oh my god what have I done!?

A/N: done! I'm hungry. I'm always hungry. I gonna go to the shop with me mum before the rain falls. See y'alls! Bye.

Wolf out :3

Second A/N: rewritten! This was kinda hard.