CreepyPasta Boyfriend Scenarios

Getting Back Together

Jeff The Killer:

I was playing on my phone until the doorbell rang. I put down my phone and opened the door.

"Hey-...... Chasity.... What's he doing here?" I looked at Chasity.

"Heh.. Well.. You see.... Jeff here-" She was then interrupted when Jeff ran towards me and hugged me.

I stiffened and blinked a few times. I relaxed and look at Jeff. "I'm sorry for cheating on you....."

He pulled away. I widened my eyes as I saw Jeff's face. There were tears strolling down his face.

For the first time. I saw Regret and Sadness in those crazy eyes.

I started to tear up and hugged Jeff. "I-I'm sorry! *hic* I'm so sorry!!" I smiled and kissed him.

"It's fine.... I'm over it already..." I hugged Jeff again while Chasity smiled softly.

'Thank you.' I mouthed at Chasity. She raised her brows and gave me a thumbs up.

'No prob.' She mouthed back.

Slenderman:

Chasity called me to go to the woods, at first I hesitated but agreed anyway.

I entered the woods and it reminded me of.... Slender. I started to tear up but wiped the tears away.

I stopped at a specific tree and saw me and Slender's initial's. I smiled sadly and heard static.

I gasped and turned around. I saw Slender with a bouqet of flowers. I covered my mouth as Slender walked towards me.

I still felt heartbroken so I backed away. He reached out to me but I continued to back away.

My back was against the tree with Slender a few feet away from me.

"Y/n..."

"Dont.. Please.." I looked down with my hand on the area where my heart is.

He stayed silent and hugged me. I flinched and tried to hold back. But I couldn't.

I sobbed. I hugged Slender's torso and tightened my grip. "Will you forgive me?"

I nodded and Slender bent down. He 'smiled' and 'kissed' me. I kissed back and hugged Slender again.

BEN Drowned:

I haven't played Majora in a while so.... I guess I'll play it..

I sat down with the disc in my console and started to play. It was good but started to glitch.

I knew who it was, "Ben..... I know it's you....."

'..... Forgive me...... Please...... Im sorry for what I've done....'

Yes No

"How can I?! You cheated on me with another woman!!"

'I know... but... Please... Give me another chance!?? Im so sorry!!'

Yes No

"..................." I looked down at my controller and hovered over 'No'

'...............'

I sighed and pressed 'Yes'

'Wait what?'

Ben came out of the TV and looked at me. I looked up and he widened his eyes.

There were tears strolling down my face. "Why......."

He hugged me and started to cry. "I'm sorry.. Im so so so sorry..."

I hugged back and we stayed like that for a while. I smiled and slept on Ben's shoulder.

He chuckled and carried me to the bed. "Night.... Y/n"

Ticci Toby:

I laid down on my bed and looked at the ceiling. I started to tear up but I held back.

I heard a knock on my window and looked over. I saw Toby there.

I gasped and sat up. He looked at me with sad eyes. I walked over to the window and opened it.

He came in with Chasity behind him. "What do you want?" He took off his googles and my eyes widened.

His eyes had bags and red. He hugged me and I hugged back. "I'm sorry..... For everything... Please.. Just... forgive me.......?"

I smiled softly and wiped his tears away. "It's fine. It's okay.." He smiled and kissed me.

Dark Link:

I looked at the Ocarina Of Time: 3D. I frowned and picked up the cartidge. I put it close to my chest and cried.

I heard the doorbell ring and I opened the door. "H-hey... Y/n" I widened my eyes and hugged Dark.

-Dark Link's POV-

I was suprised and I looked at Chasity. She just shrugged and I looked back at Y/n. I smiled and hugged her back.

-Back to Reader's POV-

"Forgive me-"

"I already did awhile ago dummy!" I looked up at Dark and kissed him. He stiffened but kissed back.

We both smiled and I hugged him again. Chasity was giggling and she left us alone for awhile.

Eyeless Jack:

Same as Toby!

I was wondering if you guys want me to add in some characters! Leave some suggestions in the comments! Bye and Stay Determined!!!