Double Murder (Female Creepypasta x Male Creepypasta Reader) [Indefinite Hiatus]

Meeting the Girls Pt. 2

A/N:

Hello there now 5 people who actually read this! So, I know it's been a while since I last uploaded a new part. Well, that would be because I didn't know what girl to do next, but i finally decided to do three. Those three being Jess, Jane, and Benny. Also, because I was too lazy and pulled multiple all-nighters in a row, which left me with basically no energy, and I'm moving soon, so that's fun, but yeah. Here's the new part and I hope you enjoy it.

You had woken up, and it was about noon already. Angel had gotten out of bed already, so naturally, you did too.

As soon as you got downstairs, you heard Angel gossiping about you, so you went to hear what she was saying. You then wished you hadn't after what happened.

"He's such a peaceful sleeper," Angel said. "I couldn't go to sleep knowing he was right there, but eventually, I did, because I knew he wouldn't hurt me, and he was asleep anyway."

"Wow," a person with a clock for an eye said. Wait a second, a clock eye? You instantly wanted to nope out of there, and you started to, but they saw you as you had just started.

"There he is!" a monochrome, colorless clown said. "Goodbye dollar store Pennywise," you said, and started running. "Get back here~," they all said in unison before chasing after you. You started thinking for a while, until you remembered Dreamer existed. "Dreamer," you started, "mind lending me a hand here?" She sighed, as if she were annoyed,but finally said, "OK, fine. But don't blame me for where we end up." "Thank you." You two were then teleported to another room in the mansion, which was dark, as if someone was still sleeping. 

You saw a TV in front of you that was on, and was playing The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask. They were at the ocean town, and on the third day. "Nope. It's another trap," you said. But just before you left, you felt a pair of hands grab your chest. You then looked back and saw someone crawling out of the TV. "You're no fun," the person said. "And, who are you," you asked the girl. "You don't know? I thought the others would've told you about me. I guess not. My name's Benny!" "Are you normal and not weird," you asked. "I wouldn't say so. I'm just a prankster. They're my form of fun, besides video games, of course.

"At least you don't wanna chase me down through the halls and try to do God knows what to me like the others," you said, clearly relieved by the fact she wasn't too bad. "Well, it's because, unlike the others, I'm not desperate for someone's attention. Now you might wanna leave before they find you." "Okay. Thanks Benny," you said before leaving. She let go of your chest and replied by saying, "Goodbye." But as soon as you left, she started having a mental breakdown. Then, she said, "It's okay Benny. Just take your time and calm down. You'll get him eventually. He just has to think you're a pretty cool person to be around. He seems so nice compared to yesterday. Just stay calm, don't do anything rash, and he'll fall for you eventually." As soon as you got 5 feet away from Benny's room, though, they were pretty much waiting for you, as if they knew you were in there for hours. "Nowhere to run," the clown said. "I have a question." "What?" they all said, clearly very confused. "All of your names, please?"

"Okay," Angel said, "well you already know me, the 'Dollar Store Pennywise' is Laughing Jill, or just Jill, if you prefer that. The one next to me in the blue mask with something coming out of the sockets is Jackie, the emo nurse is Ann, the one in the pink dress is Sally, the one with the goggles is Tami, the one with the white mask is Masky, and the one with the yellow hoodie is... Hoodie. A few of us aren't here, though. You've already met Benny, Slenda's busy, and you just haven't met Jess or Jane." "I feel like I already know those two. So goodbye." You teleported out of that situation, and ended up in another room. As soon as you breathed, however, a knife just barely scraped by your face. You didn't get cut, but it was so close to your face, you felt you were going to get cut. Then, a girl, who you already knew was Jess, walked up to you. You weren't ready to die yet, so you just stood there.

"Why are you in here," she already started asking. "Not even a sorry," you asked. She looked irritated, so you decided not to push your luck. "Fine. Sorry, I guess. Now why are you in here." "I just randomly teleported here trying to escape the mob of girls outside. I didn't know I would end u-," you were cut off by her. "All those years ago. We were friends. You slaughtered your family and left. That's what caused me to go insane before I was burned. You were the only person who talked to me and was kind to me, besides Liu."

"Oh yeah," you began, "what happened to Liu?" Jess was silent, and clearly looked disheartened. Then you remembered she was a killer, so you just put one and two together. "Oh. It's sad i couldn't say goodbye." Jess looked up, giving you a 'WTF DUDE' look. You felt like you hit a nerve, so you decided not to push it. You walked over to her, and gave her a surprise hug. She was(like I JUST said), surprised, and it took her a while to react, but eventually, she returned the hug, and said, "I missed you." "I missed you too," you responded. After a few minutes, you broke away the hug, and said you were going to go find a new hiding spot before the mob of girls found you. She understood, and you left.

There was one room that didn't have the door kicked open, besides Jess' room, and the door had a sign that said, 'Jane'. You didn't want to believe that SHE, of all people, would be in this mansion. You kicked the door open, and started to look around everywhere. Nothing was in there. You kept looking just to make sure, and when you finally finished, you sighed in relief, and were about to start walking to the door. Before you could turn around, though, you heard the sound of a door closing. You turned around relatively quickly, and saw nothing. You turned around again, and still nothing. Then, you were suddenly tackled to the floor. You looked up, and there she was. It was Jane. You were on the floor, and she was on top of you. You couldn't speak, because the girl you had known ever since you were 8 was finally right there in front of you again. You were both petrified by fear, but also ecstatic from happiness. Then, she finally...slapped you. Yep. This reunion started off with you getting tackled and slapped. (I genuinely feel bad for you. But technically me too, since I write these, so? I don't even know.)

"Are you serious," she asked. "Why are you here NOW? Why weren't you here 4 years ago?" You couldn't say anything, so you just gave her a hug, like you had with Jess. Except Jane expected it, so she quickly hugged you back. She started heavily sobbing, and you finally said, "Don't worry. I'm back." "(Y/N)! I've missed you so much! Never leave again!" "I'll try not to."

Timeskip brought to you by Jane hugging you for a while

Several hours had passed, and you were about to go back to sleep. You had succumbed to the girl mob hours ago, and this time, Benny, Jess, and Jane joined in. They went at it for about 1 hour, looking at every part of you. You were mostly fine with this, until they got to your...(If you know, you know). That was a bit too much, so you teleported out of there back into Angel's bed. You drifted off to sleep, while thinking about how insane your day was.