Before You Exit preferences and imagines

He Cheats (part two)

Toby: His POV

She was gone. I watched the door, as if she'd come running back through the door into my arms. I didn't deserve it though. Connor wasn't home but I think Riley was. I ran to his room and knocked on the door. No one. No one was here. I sat in my room, crying. She was gone and there was nothing I could do. Connor soon came through the door to see me there, a mess, crying.

"What happened?" He asked quickly rushing to me.

"She's gone. I don't deserve her."

"Toby she'll come back. Promise."

"She won't come back, not after what I did."

"What'd you do?"

"I cheated." I informed.

"Toby..." He said disappointed. "Why?"

"I'm stupid. I didn't realize what I had until it was gone." I sobbed. Connor hugged me, even though I didn't know why. I knew he was disappointed but he'd try to help me fix things.

Riley: Thomas' jaw dropped. He never thought Riley would've cheated. He pulled you into the room, closed the door, and hugged you. Connor came and saw you crying and joined the hug. Thomas explained what happened and Connor looked mad. He stormed op through the door, probably to Riley's room.

Connor's POV

I knocked on Riley's door, and I wasn't exactly happy. He answered the door with red, puffy eyes.

"She gave you everything, Riley."

You don't think I know that?" He replied letting me in. "I hate myself just as much as you all do. I hurt the love of my life and she may not forgive me."

"You don't deserve it."

"I know I don't deserve it but I still wanna try to get her back. I have to try Connor. Even if I don't deserve it."

"Fine." I spat. "Write her a song, or something."

Connor: He couldn't write music if his life depended on it. He couldn't look himself in the mirror knowing he'd actually cheated on a girl, especially the one he wanted to marry one day. The stupid alcohol messed him up and he didn't even have to consider giving it up after seeing what it did to him. He'd woken up in bed with Megan, naked, she was also naked.

The band couldn't depend on him at this point so they turned to Riley and Toby. They wrote songs, and they were great, but they were nothing compared to Connor's.

Toby wanted to fix his big brother.

"Connor, you have to at least eat."

"No."

"I brought Starbucks." Toby offered, only to be turned down again. That's when he figured out how serious this was. "He wouldn't even drink his favorite Starbucks drink." Toby informed.

"I never thought Connor would lose his inner white girl." Riley replied.

Thomas: Stupid. He felt stupid, he was stupid. Or, at least that's what he told himself. He never thought he'd lose you, especially because he made a mistake. He didn't even know that girl. He'd just met her at a show and brought her home, never thinking it through. Connor and Braiden came one day to get him out of bed and he refused.

"C'mon Thomas, you can't sit here and rot away forever." Braiden stated.

"Yeah I can."

"But that doesn't mean we'll let you." Connor retorted. Braiden grabbed his legs and Connor grabbed his arms and they pulled him to his bathroom. "At least take a shower." Connor begged.

"Fine." Thomas spat. Braiden and Connor left and Thomas hopped into the shower.

Braiden: He was dismissed from work early. Braiden went straight home and washed everything off of himself, before crying in his bed. You gave him everything, your love, time, and worst yet, your virginity. He promised he'd never take that for granted, but he went and slept with another girl. He hated himself.

Bailey (his sister) was determined to get him out of bed, and she did. She took him out for a day and unfortunately that was the day your friend got you out of the house too.

"(Y/N)." He gasped.

Chris: You were drowning in your own sorrow and you hated how you fell for him too quickly. You were too quick to fall for him and you gave him everything, but got a broken heart in return. You wrote a song about him called White Horse. (By Taylor Swift.) Then posted it on your YouTube channel. Views skyrocketed and you got a record deal. White Horse was your first single.

The next was called Shake It Off and then Blank Space. (All by Taylor Swift.) This break up was the best thing that ever happened to you.

He was there at your show one day.

"Hey (Y/N)." He grinned.