Hamilton OneShots!

LeeBury - Next Victim (Part 2)

Alright, this is a continuation of the first part, so have fun! Anyway, like always, request whatever you like, and skip to these if you don't like the lead up: ❤️❤️❤️❤️
((P.S. My auto fill knows exactly what is up, I just used the auto fill to type that- PFF))
((Also we got some angst at the end))

3rd Person POV***

Lee took a deep breath. He was in his civilian car, and in civilian clothes. He didn't want to raise any alarm to any nearby gang that might be watching. He looked out of his car window at the church, wondering why the hell he was doing this again. He took a deep breath, pushing his fears down as he stepped out of his car. He walked up to the church, opening the doors and walking in. Samuel was waiting for him, sitting a nearby chair, reading the Bible. Lee scoffs.
           "Isn't it a little counter productive to be sinning and reading the Bible?" He asks. Samuel marks his page, and closes the book.
           "Isn't that the whole point? Forgiveness of sins? We know it's sin, but we do it anyway. Speaking of sin, follow me. We can skip the small talk I think. You know the rules, I know the rules, let's go from there." He says bluntly, walking off towards his study. Lee nods, walking behind Samuel. He looks down at Samuel's butt, just a glance. He guiltily looks back up. Samuel huffs in discomfort, suddenly taking off his Chasuble, pulling it off over his head.
          "Sorry, it's quite warm today..." He sighs in relief, carrying his garment. He unlocks the door to his study, and walks in. Lee noticed that Samuel had prepared this time. A chair was already set up, toys were laid out. He also noticed that Samuel was taking off his Stole and Alb.
"Uhhhh, Wh-what are you doing?" Lee stammers. Turns out Samuel was wearing a tank top and shorts underneath the robes. Lee sighed.
"Oh thank god, I thought you were going to get naked." He says, relieved. Samuel smiles mischievously.
"I can do that if you want." He purrs. Lee blushes deeply, watching Samuel reach for the bottom of his tank top.
"N-now wait a moment! Just wait... You haven't set the timer yet..." He says, quickly stripping off his clothes and setting them aside. He was a bit aroused, but not quite there yet. Samuel smirks, biting his lip as Lee sat down in the chair. He grabs a timer and sets it for 30 minutes.
"Now, May I start?" Samuel asks, grinning as he looked over his selection of toys. Lee nods.

❤️

"Go ahead, I'm not gonna stop you." He says quietly. Samuel hums, looking over his toys. He grabs an average sized dildo.
"Hmmm... Get up Lee." He purrs. Lee nods, getting up and turning around. Samuel splutters in surprise as he saw the flared base of a plug sticking out of Lee.
"Mm! Heh! Impatient are we?" He asks, grabbing hold of the plug and gently tugging it out. Lee moans softly in relief. It slid out easily, and Samuel was impressed with the size and weight of it.
"This can't have been comfortable... Well, unless it was extremely comfortable, pressing against your prostate." He purrs, grinning. Lee thought for a moment, swallowing nervously.
"Samuel, if I tempt you to fuck me, and you give in, will you lose?" He asks. Samuel blinks, lubing up the dildo.
"Ah-... Well... I haven't... Um..." He thinks for a moment, and Lee nervously awaited an answer.
"Y-Yes. That would... make me lose... I believe. But I highly doubt you can tempt me to such a level, with all due respect Lee." He says with a chuckle. Lee blushes, flinching a bit as Samuel pressed the dildo up to his entrance, slowly pressing it in. He moans softly as the tip easily popped in, the rest gliding in smoothly.
"Ahhh... Fuck... Samuel...~" He moans Sam's name deeply, purposefully trying to be as lewd as possible. Samuel blushes a deep red, quickly realizing this would be difficult, especially if Lee was this, persuasive. Samuel slowly pumps the dildo in and out of Lee, earning quite a few lustful moans.
           "Samuel... Fuck me... Please..." He begs desperately. Sam huffs, feeling his cheeks get hot, and his pants get a bit tighter.
          "No, I will not, so stop asking... And stop swearing..." He insists, trying to keep his composure as he picked up his pace with the dildo. Lee whines.
          "Ahhh-Hh! Samuel!" He moans sharply as his prostate was hit. Samuel squirms.
          "Lee... Be quiet." He growls. Lee gives Samuel a smirk.
          "What if I decide not to be quiet?" He asks with a mischievous grin. Samuel scoffs.
          "Shame on you... You were more modest about this last time." He says with a sigh, taking out the dildo abruptly. Lee whimpers in response, shifting uncomfortably. Samuel starts taking off his shirt, much to Lee's surprise.
           "S-Samuel?" He stammers. Samuel tosses his shirt aside, and starts working on his shorts.
           "I-I've decided you're worth the repayment of my sins in jail. Well... if you'll allow me to make love to you. With your full consent." He says quietly, tossing his shorts aside, leaving him in his boxers. Lee was surprised to say the least.
           "I... You're sure? I absolutely want this- yeah... but... You're absolutely sure? This means I'm calling you in after this, the gig is up." He explains. Samuel nods.
           "I know... You have to understand though, um... let's just say, a priest doesn't necessarily get action in the bedroom... By choice of course... So even though I have all these toys... I've never used them on myself... And if you find that hard to believe, I wouldn't blame you." He admits. Lee scratches his head.