Who blackmails you?
Capricorn: Laughing Jack
Aquarius: Jeff the Killer
Pisces: Clockwork
Aries: Ben Drowned
Taurus: Nina the Killer
Gemini: Eyeless Jack
Cancer: Masky
Leo: Hoodie
Virgo: Ticci Toby
Libra: Puppeteer
Scorpio: Bloody Painter
Sagittarius: Zero