Kelly Quinn, the good and noble protector of the magical life-altering cookbook may be really the villain. What if she was really evil and still remained so even after Darbie and Hannah rid her of the poison caused as the downside of the magical garden regrowing? What would have happened if it only fueled her morally corrupt motives? What if she never really was any good and her twisted ideals only cared for her and her friends? Read to find out what would have been a darker version of the original. This is only a AU and a creative work.