Playing With The Menendez Brothers

• Chapter 2 •

This chapter does have rape and sex talk in it before you read it sooo just saying ❤️

We ran over to the court and I was playing Lyle first, " i'll go easy on you " he said and winked at you. He hit the ball easily to you and you hit back with some force and he " missed it ". Erik cheered for you. You and Lyle played until you won, they both ran up to you and hugged you.

Y/n: I told you that I could beat you

Lyle: no, I definitely let you win.

Y/n Dad: Y/N WHERE THE HELL ARE YOU.

You look at Erik and Lyle, " sorry guys, earlier I told my dad I was leaving and he wasn't paying attention " you gave them another hug, " i'll see you at dinner " and you ran back to your house.
You walk in the front door and your dad slaps you, " I fucking told you we were having dinner with the Menendez family tonight " as you held your face you said, " I was just playing tennis with there sons dad " and you ran upstairs.

After about 20 minutes, your mom came upstairs and sat beside you, she hugged you tightly " y/n i'm sorry he does this to us, he's too powerful and we will have nothing if we leave him ".

Y/n Thoughts:
My mom has been my best friend since I was born, she was the only person who knew about my secret. My dad has abused us for years. My mother was nothing before she met my father.
End of thoughts

Y/n Mom: You have to get dressed for dinner sweetheart.

Y/n: Fine i'll be down in a minute.

Your mom closed the door as she walked out and you sighed and went to your closet.

You put on a pair of black leggings and a over sized sweater ( like a knitted one ) and your long brown boots. you straighten your hair and threw on some light makeup. You ran downstairs and got into the car with your parents, because apparently it's " poor " to walk on the streets as my dad says. We pulled into the driveway and the house was amazing. I got out of the car and went up to the front door and Lyle was there.

Lyle: Hey stranger

Y/n: Wow I missed you too

You both laughed and your parents walked inside, you greeted Kitty and Jose ( Erik and lyle's parents ). Jose looked me up and down in a weird way and I seen Lyle glaring at him and I just smiled at Jose and shook his hand. I hugged Erik once I seen him.

We all sat at the table, I was between Erik and Lyle. Jose was just asking me questions about my life and stuff like that. After dinner Me, Lyle and Erik went up to Lyle's room. We were talking about school.

Lyle: soo y/n you never said how old you were

Y/n: I'm 15 but my birthday is on friday.

( okay so just pretend that it's tuesday and Lyle is 17 and Erik and Y/n are the same age )

Erik: no way, mine is too

Y/n: do you think I could stay the night please ?

Lyle: of course you can, and pick out any of my clothes and the bathroom is next door

I got up and picked out one of Lyle's shirts and walked to the bathroom.

Lyle's POV

She's acting all weird when she asked to sleep over, what if the same thing happens to her. I can't just assume, I need to find some evidence. But how could anyone do that to her.

End of his POV

Back to y/n POV

I went to change in the bathroom and Erik accidentally walked in, he covered his eyes and walked back out, " y/n i'm so sorry I didn't hear you in there ". I laughed " Erik you act like you've never seen a girl in underwear before.

Erik's POV

She said that and it hit me, i've never seen a girl in underwear before. i've always been so confused about my sexuality since everything with my dad. I just awkwardly laughed and waited for her to get done.

Erik: oh and there's an extra toothbrush under the sink

Y/n: thank you erik

Y/n POV

I opened the door once I finished changing, and Erik came in beside me. He looked me up and down and must've noticed Lyle's shirt and he just looked down and started brushing his teeth. I felt bad because I can't just decide between them. I finished brushing my teeth and looked at Erik.

Erik: Goodnight y/n

Y/n: Goodnight

I walked back to Lyle's room and before I walked in, I seen Lyle and his father having sex. I panicked and I just ran to Erik's room and shut the door quickly.

Erik: what's wrong, you look scared

Y/n: i-i saw l-lyle and..

Erik came over to me and hugged me. " i know " he whispered in my ear, I was so confused because he seemed like he knew what was happening. He sat me down on his bed.

Erik: You can't tell anyone please, you promise?

Y/n: I promise I w-won't

Erik: My dad has touched me and Lyle for a couple years now. And he has different types of sex with us..

I couldn't believe what I was hearing, the perfect american family had so many secrets.

TBC
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~