This Was A Mistake | Mattheo Riddle X Reader

chapter 31

put yalls seatbelts on for this chapter💀

the following chapter contains: mentions of self harm⚠️

Maya
It was almost Halloween, meaning there was gonna be a party.

A Halloween Party.

These party's are always know as the craziest ones, like the New Years ones.

I didn't know if Mattheo and I were going in a couple costume to the party. I wanted to..

——————

We both laid in his bed. I was laying on top of him, his legs spread out under me while we both talked and got to know each other more.

It's not that we already hadn't known each other, I just still had so much to share with him. So did he.

"I wish you were my first." He said randomly.

"Well you were mine." I blushed.

"What??" His head shot up making me turn to face him on his chest.

"What? I thought you knew." I laughed smiling.

"I forgot." He sighed.

"Ohh now I'm embarrassed about it." I whined into his neck. "Don't be. I feel special." He lifted my chin up with his finger showing me the smile that appeared on his lips.

My cheeks flushed with pink and I felt butterflies in my stomach when he said that.

"So what's your count?" My chin rested on his chest while I smiled.

"Pshh like..I don't know..." He said hesitantly. "Come on. I just reminded you that I was a fucking virgin when I met you..which is embarrassing for me." I rolled my eyes.

"A lot.." He said as he covered his eyes in embarrassment. "Man-whore." I snickered at him. "Imagine." I joked. "Stop or I'll make fun of you for being a virgin, witch." He groaned at me.

"Okay fineee." I rolled my eyes.

"Who was the best out of all of them?" I asked quietly.

"You. And I'm not saying that because you're my girlfriend. I mean- for a virgin- you're fucking crazy." He smirked at me.

I felt a sense of relief and shock.

"Hm, you like that I'm crazy in bed?"

"Yeah, like my personal whore."

"I thought I was a slut." I frowned sarcastically.

"Don't test me. I'll treat you like a whore if you'd like me to." He said hotly as he threw his head back showing his sharp jawline.

"Treat me like one on Halloween. At the Halloween party.." I traced my fingers around his upper chest in front of me.

"You bet I will." He looked back down at me.

"Are we dressing up?" I asked him.

"Are you supposed to dress up?" he asked.

"Yeah, like every year. You just weren't here for it." I smirked at him.

"Right." He said.

"We can go and shop tomorrow for our costumes?" I asked hoping he'd say yes. "No. I don't want to wear anything all corny and couple shit." He said. "I wasn't even thinking of anything cute Theo. Pleaseeee. We can do something hot." I persuaded him.

"Fine." He groaned. "Yes!" I said excitedly before moving up and pressing my lips against his.

——————