The Wrong One

First Game

///

"Are you coming to the game tonight? It's the first one of the season?"

I looked at him as we walked holding hands. I want to surprise him. Plus he has to stay for practice so he won't know. I'm driving with Santana and Britts to my place.

"No sorry, I need to watch over Beth tonight" I say using my best acting skills
"Oh, I was really hoping you'd be there" he said sad

I kissed his cheek.

"I'll see you soon" I said
"Really rach? The cheek?" He asked again

I can never just kiss his cheek without him wanting more. So I decide to tease him

"If you win the game tonight, you'll be getting more than a kiss tonight" I whispered

I could feel him get hard, so I smiled and walked toward Santana and Britney. I take a glance back to find him smiling big. I just roll my eyes

"Hurry's up B, I needs to see my niece!" Santana yelled

I jump in the car ignoring her rant on how Beth is dying to see her. Yeah right.
///
Finn POV
She's killing me over here. I can't wait to win tonight. I'm kind of sad she won't be there but, at least she'll be waiting at home. I was still standing in excitement for tonight when all of a sudden Quinn shows up

"Hey finny, can't wait to see you at the game, I'll be cheering" she said winking

What the hell??? I thought she was dating puck? She can't go for me, I'm a one woman guy now, no sides anymore. Plus I love Rachel, I'd never cheat on her.
///
Rachel POV
I was getting Beth's formula ready when I heard

"EEEKKKK!!!!"

I covered my ears. Dad had left a while ago, said he wouldn't be able to babysit as often cause of work. So here I am getting ready for the game as Britney plays with Beth and Santana attacks me.

"B!!!! Why didn't you tell me sooner, I could've gotten you a tryout earlier!?" Santana yelled
"I wanted to do it in person," I say shrugging
"You guys, it's almost five" Britney points out

I'm almost done, I just need Beth's bag and we can head out. She looks so cute, she has on a red onesie with the number five on the back with Hudson across, it's so cute. Finn got it for her at the beginning of this year.

"I can't wait to see the look on squishy teeths face when he sees you at the game" Santana says grabbing the bag

I told them, that I told him I wasn't going. I wanted to surprise him, which I am. I grab Beth and head out. Santana and Britney are in front of me as I lock the door.

"Let's go!" I tell as Beth shows me a smile
///
Finn POV
So far we're losing by two points, but it's only the first half, so I think we could pull through. I huddle up as I see the Cheerios cheering. Quinn looks right at me and winks. If Rachel were here shed probably drag her out by her hair.
///
Rachel POV
I'm hidden in the stands with Beth in my lap when I see blonde barbie wink at Finn, my Finn. No one else just Finn. Oh that hoe gonna get it later.

Right now they're loosing by two, I can see Finn but he doesn't realize I'm here. I just sit because I see he has his game face on.
///

Later into the game

///
Still Rachel POV
We still need one more point to tie, then I hear,

"Let's go number five!!! I believe in you!"

I turn to see Quinn cheering for Finn. If I didn't have Beth with me, that girl would be dragged. Finn sees Quinn and then he looks above to see me with Beth. I see he noticed us so I smile big, and lift Beth's hand up, as if she were cheering. He smiles back and continues the game.
///
Quinn POV
I cheered and he looked! I knew he liked me. I wish Berry was here to see her man smiling at me.
///
Rachel POV
There's only one minute left and we're winning by three, it's like Beth has this power over Finn to do good in his games, because right after he saw us, we started scoring.

......

TOUCHDOWN!!!!! I stand up holding Beth as all the cheerleaders cheer. I'm still holding Beth when all the football players start heading off the field as I run to Finn. I smile real big as a sweaty Finn approaches me.

"You did it!!" I smile

Beth claps her hands while laughing

"I thought you said you weren't going to come" Finn smiles happy I'm here

He was holding me close when I smirked

"Surprise" I said smiling

Finn kissed me passionately as I held Beth.

"I'm so happy you came, and brought this little princess" he said grabbing Beth

Everyone awed as Finn kissed the top of Beth's head. I smile, we look like the perfect family right now. I love it.