The Wrong One

Memory Lane

///
Finn and Rachel were making out on her bed. It was getting a little more heated when Rachel pushed him away.

"I can't do this," she pulls away
"Yes you can, here have another wine cooler" he said
"I'm president of the celibacy club, I took a vow" she argues
"So did kitty and Bree and I did them" Finn replies
"What about puck, he's your best friend" She says still unsure
"Come on we're in high school do you think any one of us is going to give a damn in three years" Finn asks
"Ok but you can't  tell anyone I'll lose my rep" She said as Finn kissed her and in between he said
"Our secret baby"
"Wait what about protection?" She pull away
"Trust me I got it, this is more than just a hookup for me" he says looking at her
Then he starts kissing her neck
///
"You know it sucks for you" 

"You got me drunk off of wine coolers and I was feeling fat that day,"

Rachel tells him

"But it was a mistake.....you're a Lima loser and you're always going to be a Lima loser" She says on the verge of tears, because she can't believe she's going to have a baby.
///
"This isn't fair! He's getting everything and he doesn't even deserve it!" Finn yells kicking a chair

"Woah, what's your problem Finn? We're just tying to help out our friends" she says
"It's not right!" He yells
"What's not right? Helping our struggling friends, because there is nothing wrong with that" Mercedes yells back
"Pucks, not the father I am!" He yells again
///
Rachel POV
I just look at his hazel eyes and I grab an egg and cracked it on his head. I laugh and then I bite my lips to keep from bursting into a fit of giggles. Finn just blinks his eyes. Then before I know it he throws some brown sugar in my face. I scoff and throw some more sugar at him. Then he grabs some from the bowl

"ah, that was perfectly measured" I laugh getting some regular sugar

Before I know it Finn and I are having a food fight. When we run out of things to throw at each other, we stop and look at each other. He walks closer to me moving a sugar covered piece of hair behind my ear. I look down avoiding eye contact still laughing a little.
///
"I cracked open my piggyback" I just stare at him and the money "it's for you and it"

"It is a she" I say plainly

He smiles

"Cool" he smiles again "told you I wasn't a dead beat" he says handing me the cash

"Look Finn this is sweet but.." He interrupts "I can get more" he says looking down
"Everyone thinks I'm a screw up cause I think schools for suckers " I look at him sympathetically cause I don't think that
"We can get a house, some furniture, we could be a family" he says
-
"Ok I did, but I made all those cupcakes, I'm all for being a team player, but my family comes first" he tells me confident

I just smile, Finn can be really sweet when he wants to be

"I get it, and I'm sorry, I should've never called you a Lima loser" I say rubbing his chest "you're not, you're special, and sweet and romantic" I look at him "and a good enough person to realize we are not going to steal money from a friend in a wheelchair"
///
Rachel POV
"Hey I got you something" Finn says going next to me and handing me a book

How to raise a baby on five dollars a day

I just laugh and take it