Murder - EJ x Reader - COMPLETED

~9~

Just so y'all don't get your Jack's confused :)
*Jack: Eyeless Jack
*LJ: Laughing Jack
"Well that was eventful. Now, who wants some candy?" I turned around to see Laughing Jack standing there.

Jack's grip on my hand tightened a bit.

I looked over at him, giving him a confused glance.

"(Y/N), would you like some candy, my dear?" LJ smiled at me.

"Um, sure?" I reached my hand out, but Jack pulled it away.

"Don't take candy from him, it's poisoned." He warned.

LJ have a hurt look and placed a hand over his heart.

"Well, EJ, I'm quite offended. I would never poison her!" He scoffed.

Jack ignored him, and continued walking.

"Wait! I have a favor to ask of you,
(Y/N)!" He called after us.

Jack and I paused, and I turned to look at LJ.

"What is it?" I asked.

"I need your help with something regarding BEN" He smiled innocently.

"What about him?" I squinted at him, going full mama bear mode.

This bitch better not think he can hurt my Benny bear, nuh uh boi.

"Well... can we speak in private? It's a bit personal." He looked over at Jack.

"Anything you have to say to (Y/N), you can say to me." Jack's grip on my hand tightened.

"It's... well- it's about my...." LJ seemed to be arguing with himself.

"Jack... I think you should go, he needs a friend right now and based on what I've heard, you two aren't very close at all. Trust me, if anything happens, you can rip him to shreds." I smiled reassuringly at Jack and pushed him away lightly.

Jack hesitated, looking between LJ and I.

"Fine." He sighed.

Jack walked off, and I pulled LJ into a nearby room.

"Okay, what is it?" I asked.

"I may or may not be questioning my sexuality." He said quickly.

"In what way?" I asked.

He shrugged.

"Are you bi or gay?" I questioned.

"The second one." He shifted uncomfortably.

"Are you not comfortable with it yet?" I asked.

He shook his head and I placed a hand on his shoulder.

"It's perfectly fine. You are who you are and you should be okay with that." I smiled.

He nodded to himself and pulled me in for a hug.

I patted his back reassuringly.

"Sooo... you and BEN, huh?" I teased.

"I'm not even sure if he's gay or not." LJ said.

"Oh trust me, he is." I rolled my eyes.

"How do you know?" He asked.

"The one time I've been in his room, there were Magic Mike posters on the walls. That in itself is enough proof." I shook my head, laughing a bit.

LJ smiled and thanked me before leaving the room.

I sighed and quietly closed the door behind me.

Jack stood across the hallway, leaning against the wall.

"What was it about?" He asked.

"None of your concern." I raised an eyebrow.

"And trust me, you have nothing to worry about." I said, grabbing his hand.

We went downstairs to the living room and saw BEN and LJ laughing together.

I smiled at them and waved.

BEN waved back and LJ smiled.

"Hm, those two seem awfully close, don't you think?" Jack said.

"Yep, that's a good thing." I said.

"(Y/N)!!!!" Jeff yelled.

I looked over at him and he came running towards me.

Jack pulled me away and I rolled my eyes.

"(Y/N)! Have you seen my knife?! She's missing!!" Jeff cried.

"No, why would I have your knife?" I asked, peeking my head out from around Jack.

"You had it last time so I assumed you keep taking it." He said.

"No, Jeff, I haven't seen it. Sorry." I laughed.

"What?! Why is that funny? She could be hurt- or worse! Dead!!!" He fell to the floor dramatically.

I bursted out laughing at his stupid behavior.

Jack even chuckled a bit.

"(Y-Y/N)!" Toby yelled.

"Yeah Toby?" I asked, wiping a tear away.

"M-Masky is a-attacking me because
he-e thinks I st-stole his cheeseca-ake! Help m-e!" He ran behind me with Masky not far behind.

I backed into a corner and kept my arms out so Masky couldn't get to him.

"Masky!!! Leave my child alone!" I yelled.

"He stole my cheesecake!" He yelled back.

"Don't make me call Jack and Jeff on you!" I screamed.

Masky froze for a second, before slowly backing away.

"Mmhm, that's what I thought." I said.

I turned around and patted Toby on the head before walking back over to Jeff and Jack.

"Damn, using us as defense? That was smart and flattering." Jeff patted me on the back.

"He's more scared of Jack, but I figured you'd be sad if I didn't include you." I said.

"What?! Nuh uh!" Jeff crossed his arms.

Jack laughed and fist bumped me.

"(Y/N), Slender wants to see you!"