Maeve prefers to be single in life, or so she says. Her sister, Raegin, doesn't believe her and sets out to prove it, creating a sibling rivalry with a forfeit to the loser. Raegin creates Maeve's dating profile, then let's Maeve find it out for herself when a nice man messages her. To prove her sister wrong, Maeve decides to give the dating scene a hesitant attempt. Time passes, and a few men have failed at being Mr Right, but the taste of victory still puts a damper on her mood. Just as she's ready to delete the account and claim victory, a message comes through to her Dating inbox. He was perfect, in every way she could want... But of course, the path of love never has run smoothly... Which sister will win the battle of wits? How difficult can finding Mr Right be?